Buddha Buck writes:
|
| How would you interpret:
|
| V:1 clef=bass middle=c

Go talk to some of the Early Music crowd.  A few  centuries
ago,  it  was  common to draw the clef symbols at different
positions on the staff.  I don't know  if  that  particular
usage was ever common, but there's no question about how to
draw it.  The bass clef is a (highly-stylized) "F", and the
little  curl  in the center is drawn on the F line.  To get
the above, you'd put that curl slightly lower, so  it's  in
the space.  Then the middle line would represent c (or C).

| or (perversely)
|
| K:Cmaj clef=bass middle=^c

I love it!

What I'd expect good software to do is give a warning  "The
key of Cmaj doesn't contain ^c; ^ ignored."

If the key does have ^c, then this is merely redundant, and
should be accepted as if there were nothing funny about it.

Maybe we could officially ban accidentals  in  the  middle=
clause.   But  I  wouldnt' bother; it would outlaw harmless
humor like this.


To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html

Reply via email to