Great stuff Andrew.
I should have specified "extremely narrow for implementations in our universe as we generally understand it".
This is an old discussion, so I'm not going to rehash it. The enemy of implementation is *tractability*, not "will this work in theory if I throw astronomical quantities of computing resources at the problem". This is a crucial point that still seems to escape many people. It is fairly evident from what we know of the mathematics that this is the case. You have a wide diversity of choices in theoretical designs, but only because while dabbling in theory you can ignore engineering tractability in practice.
My perspective comes from reverse engineering the brain. In doing this, I am exposed to the many compromises and innovations evolution was forced to make.
But these are very specific solutions to very specific problems, such as how to recognize the minute differences between thousands of faces, or learning to understand speech, remember events that occur over 80 years. And the specific solutions of how we cognitively deal with complex decision making tasks is a problem we're just beginning to scratch at.
The more one studies the specifics of the solutions the brain uses, the more one realizes the incredible varieties of strategies that could have been used, yes economically, and yes in our universe.
Evolution was forced into certain compromises and choices not because they were the only solutions to the problem but because evolution is heavily bound by its own historical precedent.
If it helps you, I'll restate it this way: Almost every major AI effort is a theoretically correct design. Extremely few, if any, are reasonably tractable AI designs in our universe. The problem has never been about theoretical correctness, at least not if one has a reasonable understanding of the underlying problem.
Yes, I understood your point. I do have a reasonable understanding of the underlying problem. The difference is simply one of perspective. I see limitless solutions, you see a narrow track.
Finding someone with a contrary opinion on any topic is easy. That they have an opinion at all does not make their opinion meaningful or valid ipso facto.
I think there is far more agreement on the basics than you seem to think. Not being able to discern between the idle chatter of people who don't grok the underlying subject matter and people with a serious clue will give you that impression though. There are a lot of airplane enthusiasts who do not understand the basic physical design principles of powered flight. For any topic that attracts fanboys and cranks, it often takes a great deal of genuine expertise to separate the cranks and fanboys from people with genuine expertise.
I've been involved with the hard AI, the weak AI and the neurophys approaches to these problems at an academic level. There is very little agreement there.
All CPUs are technologically identical for all intents and purposes, and commodities. The differences revolve almost entirely around the manufacturing costs and efficiencies. This is a terrible example actually, as it is an industry where competitors differentiate themselves by manufacturing economics.
So, if you had a company that made its money sorting sets of data in a competitive market, you are saying that the selection of sorting algorithm is irrelevant to your ability to survive in the marketplace?
I'm not a big believer in self-improving AI, at least not in the sense that it often seems many others use that term. The core design will have to be pretty close from the beginning for an implementation to even be plausible in practice.
The primary difference is that AI will be a business where the economics is bound almost entirely by "knowledge" rather than more traditional manufacturing cost structures. Even nominally pure information products, such as software, are bound by the manufacturing cost of the code, though the overall process starts to show symptoms of knowledge-bound economics.
So by knowledge you mean essentially empirical facts, that 1 + 2 = 3.
The hard part in AGI is not finding that knowledge, but in developing an agent that can distill that knowledge. That's what we do, as people.
The problem with knowledge, is that it has to be "learned". One can't simply buy knowledge, and the whole point of intelligence is to
That's certainly not true. I can buy a chemistry textbook full of essentially mathematical knowledge of how atoms interact. That knowledge doesn't have to be learned either, I can use it straight from the book.
I think you were thinking of something else when you discuss knowledge, and if so, you'll need to clarify it.
manufacture knowledge from data. Economics and economic advantage is all about knowledge -- that is the real value of intelligence after all.
Any machine intelligence will quickly be in a position of clear economic advantage in the marketplace which will allow it to maximize its rate of knowledge acquisition. Outside of a relatively small bootstrap window where capital and implementation efficiencies will still be factors that are above the noise floor such that there would be genuine competition between two roughly identical designs, no other implementation will ever be able to catch the first because the first will be able to outmaneuver any subsequent implementations in the market through superior knowledge. Novice versus grandmaster.
This perspective is all dependent on your view that there is essentially only one solution to the problem.
From my perspective, if you imagine 10 different companies developing AGiin different directions, they'll be discovering different kinds of knowledge about the regularities of economic reality. So while company X's AGI performs well in market X, company Y's AGI cleans up market Y.
-------
To unsubscribe, change your address, or temporarily deactivate your subscription, please go to http://v2.listbox.com/member/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
