It... might be the case, but then I'm pretty certain it'd override the
previous self-ratifications and just make it so that everyone's had
these ribbons for a year.
Also, the rules are very strict on "nothing self-ratifies unless we
explicitly say it does", and nowhere does it say the date of the report
is something that is self-ratifying.
On 2018-02-12 13:07, Kerim Aydin wrote:
When you ratify a report that includes a specific "this is the
date this report is for", my understanding is that this modifies
the values for that date. Just like my recent attempt to ratify
"On (date) there were no elections".
In this case, you would have ratified everyone's ribbon holdings
for a year ago. However, we have reports from the fall that
ratified in late 2017, that state at a later date you didn't have the
ribbons. So I think your attempt failed...perhaps? That now the
legal historical record is that those were the ribbon holdings
from early 2017 until the next actual report ratified last year.
Remember, we apply very strict scrutiny to scams and tiny
errors are enough to stop it.
On Mon, 12 Feb 2018, Alexis Hunt wrote:
The date is still off, though---it happened one week after the previous
report.
On Sun, 11 Feb 2018 at 19:19, Cuddle Beam <cuddleb...@gmail.com> wrote:
Oh shit, true. Well, OK.
On Mon, Feb 12, 2018 at 1:17 AM, Aris Merchant <
thoughtsoflifeandligh...@gmail.com> wrote:
It was in eir previous report.
-Aris
On Sun, Feb 11, 2018 at 4:15 PM Cuddle Beam <cuddleb...@gmail.com>
wrote:
CoE:
2018-02-12 Telnaior +K (self-ratification)
You haven't earned it YET, self-ratification is after its undoubted
for a
week, as per R2201.
On Mon, Feb 12, 2018 at 1:06 AM, Telnaior <j...@iinet.net.au> wrote:
TAILOR'S RIBBON REPORT
----------------------
Date of this report: 2017-02-12
Date of last report: 2017-01-31
Festivity: 0
Players' ribbon holdings:
ROGCBMUVIPLWKAT
Alexis ROGCBMUVIP WKA
Aris R MUV P
Corona
Cuddle Beam C M V W
G. ROGCBMUVIPLW AT
Gaelan C MUV A
Murphy CB UV A
nichdel OGCBMUV P W AT
o ROG BMUV W AT
omd C UV KA
pokes
Publius [1] C MUV
Quazie O C MUV KA
Telnaior KA
Trigon
Josh T. [3] UV A
V.J. Rada MU LW
Non-players' ribbon holdings:
ROGCBMUVIPLWKAT
ais523 ROGCBMUV PLWKAT
aranea ROGCBM V PLW A
ATMunn A
babelian U
Bayushi MU
Bede M W
Chuck M
grok O BMUV
Ienpw III UV
K W
Ørjan M V
Roujo V
Sprocklem MUV W A
stadjer W
Tanner Swett C M
Tekneek M
Tiger BM
tmanthe2nd UV
Veggiekeks C UV
Yally M
Zachary W [2] U
[1] Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
[2] Zachary Watterson
[3] 天火狐
The rules for Ribbons are set out in rule 2438. A quick guide to how
most Ribbons work: various events cause you to "earn" a Ribbon; you
then "qualify for" that Ribbon for 7 days. While you qualify for a
Ribbon (and do not already own that Ribbon, and have not owned it
recently), any player can "award" you that Ribbon. A few Ribbons
work differently; see rule 2438 for details.
Approximate summary of how each type of Ribbon can be gained:
Red Author an adopted proposal that amends a Power-3+ rule
Orange Author a proposal that is unanimously adopted
Green Hold an elected office for 30 days with no late duties
Cyan Deputise for an office
Blue Judge a CFJ without violating time limits to do so
Magenta Acknowldge Agora's Birthday
Ultraviolet Become Champion (typically by winning the game)
Violet Gain a Patent Title (except Champion, degrees)
Indigo Gain a degree
Platinum Become the Speaker
Lime Coauthor three adopted proposals within 7 days
White Never have had a White Ribbon, or be gifted one by
someone
who has never gifted a White Ribbon
blacK Awardable only by proposal or scam
GrAy Awarded monthly at the Tailor's discretion
Transparent Qualify for 5 Ribbons in the same week (ones you already
have count)
History of Ribbon holdings:
2014-11-04 aranea +W (new to Ribbons)
2014-11-04 aranea +C (deputising for Tailor)
2014-11-06 Sprocklem +W (new to Ribbons)
2014-11-09 omd +C (deputising for King Azaz)
2014-11-14 Alexis +C (deputising for Herald)
2015-01-07 G. +C (deputising for Referee)
2015-04-17 stadjer +W (new to Ribbons)
2015-05-01 aranea +R (Proposal 7736)
2015-05-01 aranea +O (Proposal 7735)
2015-05-01 aranea +L (Proposal 7735-37)
2015-05-01 G. +R (Proposal 7734)
2015-05-01 G. +O (Proposal 7738)
2015-05-01 G. +L (Proposal 7734,38,39)
2015-05-01 G. +P (appointed Speaker)
2015-05-12 ais523 +O (Proposal 7742)
2015-05-12 Alexis +P (appointed Speaker)
2015-05-13 Alexis +G (as Tailor)
2015-05-22 G. +B (CFJ 3448)
2015-05-23 Alexis +B (CFJ 3447)
2015-05-24 G. +W (gifted by aranea)
2015-06-09 ais523 +G (as Prime Minister)
2015-06-29 Alexis +M
2015-06-29 aranea +M
2015-06-29 ais523 +M
2015-06-29 the Warrigal +M
2015-06-29 Sprocklem +M
2015-06-29 Tiger +M
2015-06-29 G. +M
2015-06-29 Bede +M
2015-06-30 Gaelan +M
2015-06-30 aranea +A
2015-06-30 Alexis +O (Proposal 7753)
2015-07-10 G. +G (as Arbitor)
2015-07-12 aranea +V ("Unchampion")
2015-07-26 Alexis +A
2015-07-28 aranea +B (CFJ 3449)
2015-08-03 ais523 +V ("Silver Quill 2015/07")
2015-08-10 Tiger +B (CFJ 3451)
2015-08-11 omd +K (by Proposal 7784)
2015-08-11 ais523 +K (by Proposal 7784)
2015-08-11 Alexis +K (by Proposal 7784)
2015-08-11 Alexis +R (Proposal 7772)
2015-08-11 Alexis +P
2015-08-17 omd +A
2015-08-21 ais523 +U
2015-08-21 omd +U
2015-08-21 Alexis +U
2015-09-30 Gaelan +A
2015-10-08 Bede +W (new to Ribbons)
2015-10-21 G. +A
2015-11-27 Murphy +C (deputising for Secretary)
2015-11-28 ais523 +P
2015-11-29 Murphy +A
2016-02-21 Sprocklem +A
2016-06-26 nichdel +C (deputising for Registrar)
2016-06-30 Tekneek +M
2016-06-30 nichdel +M
2016-07-14 nichdel +A
2016-08-01 omd +V ("Distributor")
2016-08-20 ais523 +A
2016-10-13 Alexis +C (deputising for Referee)
2016-10-13 Alexis +A
2016-11-10 Alexis +V ("Princess of Agora", via
dictatorship)
2017-03-26 Tanner Swett +C (deputising for ADoP)
2017-04-18 Quazie +C (deputising for Superintendent)
2017-04-18 Publius [1] +C (deputising for Registrar)
2017-05-10 o +O (proposal 7846)
2017-05-10 o +G (as Secretary)
2017-05-10 o +B (CFJ 3485)
2017-05-10 o +W (new to Ribbons)
2017-05-10 o +T (+OGBWR)
2017-05-10 o +R (proposal 7846)
2017-05-18 ais523 +C (deputising for Tailor)
2017-05-18 o +A
2017-05-21 nichdel +G (as Assessor)
2017-05-21 nichdel +B (CFJ 3499)
2017-05-21 nichdel +U
2017-05-21 nichdel +P
2017-05-21 nichdel +W (new to Ribbons)
2017-05-21 nichdel +T (+GBUPW)
2017-05-22 ais523 +B (CFJ 3504)
2017-05-22 ais523 +T (+OBUVC)
2017-05-23 grok +B (CFJ 3507)
2017-05-24 nichdel +O (proposal 7852)
2017-05-25 tmanthe2nd +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 G. +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 CuddleBeam +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Ienpw III +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 nichdel +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 o +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Ørjan +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Aris +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Murphy +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Quazie +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Publius [1] +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Sprocklem +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Veggiekeks +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Roujo +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 Gaelan +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 [2] +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-05-25 grok +V ("Badge of the Great Agoran Revival")
2017-06-02 G. +I
2017-06-05 ais523 +R (proposal 7853)
2017-06-05 Quazie +O (proposal 7855)
2017-06-05 grok +O (proposal 7857)
2017-06-10 Veggikeks +C (deputising for Reportor)
2017-06-10 Murphy +B (CFJ 3522)
2017-06-24 ais523 +W (status of ambiguous Ribbon
determined)
2017-06-24 Alexis +W (status of ambiguous Ribbon
determined)
2017-06-28 Quazie +K
2017-06-29 Quazie +M
2017-06-29 CuddleBeam +M
2017-06-29 Publius [1] +M
2017-06-29 Chuck +M
2017-06-29 Yally +M
2017-06-29 grok +M
2017-06-29 Aris +M
2017-06-29 Bayushi +M
2017-06-30 o +M
2017-06-30 V.J. Rada +M
2017-06-30 Ørjan +M
2017-07-04 CuddleBeam +W
2017-07-06 o +A
2017-08-23 K +W
2017-08-24 Quazie +A
2017-09-06 Aris +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 babelian +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Bayushi +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Gaelan +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 grok +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Ienpw III +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Murphy +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 o +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Publius +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Quazie +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Sprocklem +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 tmanthe2nd +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 V.J. Rada +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Veggiekeks +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Zachary W [2] +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 Josh T. [3] +U (Apathy)
2017-09-06 V.J. Rada +W (never owned before)
2017-09-13 Quazie +P
2017-09-26 ais523 +L (proposals 7881, 7882, 7886)
2017-09-26 V.J. Rada +L (proposals 7881, 7885, 7888)
2017-09-29 Aris +R (proposal 7889)
2017-10-03 G. +T (U [Apathy], P, O [proposal 7899],
C [Assessor], B [CFJ 3567])
2017-10-09 G. -T (ratification of an incorrect ADoP
report)
2017-10-23 G. +T (by proposal 7922)
2017-10-28 ATMunn +A
2017-11-02 Alexis +I (self-ratification)
2017-11-02 Alexis +G (self-ratification)
2017-11-29 Josh T. [3] +A
----- time of last report -----
2017-12-11 Telnaior +A
2018-02-04 Cuddle Beam +C
2018-02-05 Aris +P
2018-02-12 Telnaior +K (self-ratification)
