Did we ever decide what happens with payments for failed actions? My vague
recollection was that “I spend one coin TO do x” refunds when X is ineffective,
but “I spend one coin AND do x” doesn’t. Is this correct?
Either way, proto: {
Create a P3.1 rule titled Spending: {
When the rules specify that the an action CAN be performed by transferring or
destroying a set of assets, then the action CAN be performed by announcement if
the performing player, in the same message and solely for this purpose,
transfers or destroys the assets as specified by the rules. Players CAN destroy
or transfer assets for this purpose. An attempt to destroy or transfer assets
in order to perform an IMPOSSIBLE action is itself INEFFECTIVE.
For indestructible assets, "spending the asset" is a synonym for transferring
it to Agora. For all other assets, "spending the asset" is a synonym for
destroying it.
} [P3.1 to override Assets, generally allowing asset destruction by
announcement]
[Amend each rule allowing asset spending to perform an action to use the new
terminology]
}
> On Feb 26, 2018, at 10:49 AM, Reuben Staley <reuben.sta...@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Frick. That was definitely supposed to be (0, -1). Oh well. Also, I'm
> allowed to substitute 1 corn for 3 apples. But I guess since the moved were
> ineffective, I have destroyed none of my assets.
>
> El 26 feb. 2018 11:46, "Cuddle Beam" <cuddleb...@gmail.com> escribió:
>
>> You can't move from (+1,0) to (-1,-1), nor did you destroy apples for any
>> of it.
>>
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (0, 0) [Black] to (0, +1)
>> [Black]
>> .
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (0, +1) [Black] to (-1, +1)
>> [Black] .
>> I transfer all of the apples and lumber from the orchard there to my
>> inventory.
>>
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (-1, +1) [Black] to (0, +1)
>> [Black].
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (0, +1) [Black] to (+1, +1)
>> [Black].
>> I transfer all of the stone and ore from the mine there to my inventory.
>>
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (+1, +1) [Black] to (+1, 0)
>> [Black].
>> I destroy two of my apples to move as from (+1, 0) [Black] to (+1, -1)
>> [White].
>> I transfer all of the corn and cotton from the farm there to my inventory.
>>
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (+1, -1) [White] to (0, -1)
>> [White].
>> I destroy one of my apples to move as from (0, -1) [White] to (-1, -1)
>> [White] .
>> I transfer all of the stone and ore from the mine there to my inventory.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> On Mon, Feb 26, 2018 at 5:23 PM, Reuben Staley <reuben.sta...@gmail.com>
>> wrote:
>>
>>> No one's gonna do this? Okay then.
>>>
>>> I destroy one corn. I move as from (0, 0) to (+1, 0), then to (-1, -1). I
>>> transfer all the ore and stones to my inventory. I move to (-1, -2).
>>>
>>> El 25 feb. 2018 19:23, "Reuben Staley" <reuben.sta...@gmail.com>
>> escribió:
>>>
>>> This is your local Cartographor calling in to remind everyone that as
>>> yesterday ended an Agoran week, Agora has created in possession of the
>>> following facilities the following items:
>>>
>>> The mine at (-1, -1): 3 stones, 2 ore
>>> The mine at (+1, +1): 3 stones, 2 ore
>>> The orchard at (-1, +1): 3 apples, 3 lumber
>>> The farm at (+1, -1): 3 corn, 3 cotton
>>>
>>> Since these facilities are all built on Public Land, everyone can collect
>>> from them, but as they are all on Preserved Land, no one can spend assets
>>> to upgrade them.
>>>
>>> Additionally, since there is Public, Non-preserved land, any player can
>>> build facilities on them. Just be aware that others will be able to
>> modify
>>> your facilities if you choose to build on this land. Fortunately, as this
>>> is a new week, a land auction can now commence.
>>>
>>> For the following 5 auctions, I am the announcer and auctioneer, and the
>>> minimum bid is 1 coin:
>>>
>>> AUCTION 1: The lot is the white land unit at (-1, -2)
>>> AUCTION 2: The lot is the white land unit at ( 0, -2)
>>> AUCTION 3: The lot is the white land unit at (+1, -2)
>>> AUCTION 4: The lot is the black land unit at (-1, +2)
>>> AUCTION 5: The lot is the black land unit at ( 0, +2)
>>>
>>> As far as I know, the rules that define asset generation and land
>> auctions
>>> stand uncontested, so both of these moves are valid and required.
>>>
>>
