On Monday, 10 September 2018 03:28, Reuben Staley <[email protected]> 
wrote:
> Second one is denied since it was already white when you tried to turn it 
> gray and therefore INEFFECTIVE.

I don't believe that matters? Rule 2003 says:

      3. 2 apples to set Land Type of a Land Unit which e owns to any
         Land Type other than Aether, whether or not e is located at
         that Land Unit.

No mention of what the Land Unit's type must be _before_ the change.

> Also, show me where you paid upkeep on that one and I'll add it back.

If the land unit _isn't_ grey, then you are correct, but if it _is_ (which I 
maintain is the case), then the loom wouldn't have belonged to me at the time 
upkeep was due, and Rule 2560 (which says failing to pay upkeep destroys the 
facility) would be overpowered by Rule 2565 (which says preserved facilities 
can't be destroyed).

-twg

Reply via email to