> I think that once a person have been punished for breaking a pledge, the > pledge is done (as e can't be punished twice, there's no requirement > anymore). So the result of the finger-point, if e is punished, is to end > the pledge. (Whether this is true is a general question about pledges, > maybe CFJ-worthy).
Maybe, maybe not. After all, in the minutes that have elapsed since your pointed finger, a great many new things have happened that CuddleBeam failed to track. So perhaps players can continue to point eir fingers at CuddleBeam for new violations of eir pledge until e is forcibly deregistered... :-) I cause nichdel to Point eir Finger at Cuddle Beam for failing to track a bunch more things in the time that elapsed since G. Pointed eir Finger. > On Oct 1, 2018, at 7:15 PM, Kerim Aydin <[email protected]> wrote: > > > >> On Mon, 1 Oct 2018, Cuddle Beam wrote: >> I pledge the following: I pledge to be the recordkeepor of absolutely >> everything. > > Clever! Really, really clever. I like this. > > I act on behalf of Gaelan to publish: > Notice of Honour > +1 CuddleBeam (for taking the burden of tracking my bank balance from me). > -1 Ouri (more karma decay for zombies) > > I point my finger at CuddleBeam for Oathbreaking (breaking the above > Pledge), as e is not tracking absolutely everything. > > I think that once a person have been punished for breaking a pledge, the > pledge is done (as e can't be punished twice, there's no requirement > anymore). So the result of the finger-point, if e is punished, is to end > the pledge. (Whether this is true is a general question about pledges, > maybe CFJ-worthy). > > I think it is beyond a reasonable doubt that e isn't keeping records. I > believe being "recordkeepor of X", by common definition, requires em to > actually keep records. As the claim is so extraordinary, the burden of > proof is on em, not us. I invite em to prove me wrong. To do so, I have > SHA-512 hashed the current balance of my checking account (plus some > salt that's not part of the record): > > ccd0019a73ade101456525ef141cf6f65e5627bbfcae82d2b18c326382b2ee1a > 7284ac8cb3649ffbf5c36794779931acfabf1ef97e1b932ba3dd6fc615979454 > > If e is tracking this, e can publish what it is, and e is invited to > demonstrate. > >
