Speaking of, as a pedant, and a literal nomic player, I'd like to
point out the following.

kiako said:

> Using an LLM is an inherently antisocial behavior, which does not mesh well 
> with an intrinsically social game. The only value of an LLM, as currently 
> marketed and as primarily used, is
>
>   * to avoid reading text produced by humans,
>   * to avoid writing text needing to be read by humans,
>   * to avoid learning/practicing skills, and, in general,
>   * to avoid communicating with humans.

And, someone might say "that's not antisocial, that's asocial! People
can be reclusive!"
Firstly - if you are playing a game that requires human interaction
you basically forfeit your right to not interact with people.
Secondly - playing a social game like nomic means that you have
entered into a social contract by the terms of "I am investing my
human time and creativity. You invest yours." Using an LLM devalues
this by replacing genuine human emotion with synthetic automated text,
essentially sending the message "You aren't worth the effort it takes
me to think". What's more, it introduces paranoia. Players will think,
"Am I interacting with my friend or with some bot?" Finally, it
undermines the very purpose of the social gathering, which is to be
with other people. So, yes, this isn't just asocial behaviour; using
LLms is antisocial behaviour because it reduces trust and cohesion in
a group.
--
juniper

Reply via email to