ais523 wrote:

On Wed, 2026-09-02 at 23:37 +0300, msh210 via agora-business wrote:
kiako's points make a lot of sense to me, and I want to add my voice in
support fwiw.  My objection to the use of AI isn't really about whether
a language model can produce a coherent proposal or CFJ argument.  Let's
even suppose it can, without error.  Still, what gets displaced when a
participant lets software stand in for eir own engagement?  The life of
the game.  If 4st has a blot, I revoke it, paying the fee to do so,
which is seven spendies.  This game works best because people, thinking
humans, are actually present in it: reading what others have written,
weighing arguments, building on precedent, and taking responsibility for
their own actions.  A model that acts on someone's behalf hollows out
that presence even when the output looks fine on the surface.  Plus, the
other points kiako made are important also, such as the volunteer-labor
issue.

CFJ: msh210 revoked a blot from 4st in the above-quoted message.

Evidence: 4st did have a blot immediately prior to the message (created
voluntarily at around 18:54 on 2 September 2026), and this is the first
message that might have transferred or destroyed it.

Arguments: This blot-revocation action appeared in the middle of a
paragraph on an unrelated topic, which was part of a thread on an
unrelated topic, and the message was not flagged for the Referee;
although I do try to check every public message for missed actions
prior to posting the report (which is how I noticed this), it's quite
plausible that I might have missed it (and I did the first time I read
the email in question). Does that make the action too unclear to
succeed?

I think we have precedent that tabled action intents don't work if made
like this, but the action in question is not a tabled action, and so
the existing precedents don't apply because the relevant rules are
different.

Gratuituous arguments:

I would probably have overlooked this if it hadn't been
pointed out (msh210 also privately alerted me on Discord).

That said, actions in general need only be specified "clearly and
unambiguously", while tabled actions also need to be specified
"conspicuously" and "without obfuscation". I think "burying it in
the middle of an unrelated paragraph" falls under "conspicuously",
so n/a here as revoking blots is not a tabled action.

Gratuituous evidence:

Rule 478 (Fora), excerpt

      Where the rules define an action that a person CAN perform "by
      announcement", that person performs that action by, in a single
      public message, specifying the action and setting forth intent to
      perform that action by sending that message, doing both clearly
      and unambiguously.

Rule 1728 (Tabled Actions), excerpt

      A person, acting as emself, CAN by announcement table an intent
      (syn.  "intend") to perform a tabled action, clearly,
      conspicuously, explicitly, and without obfuscation specifying the
      action, the method (including non-default parameter values), and,
      optionally, conditions.


--
[ANSC H:GE]

Reply via email to