ttttpf

--
juniper

On Thu, 3 Sept 2026, 06:38 msh210 via agora-business, <
[email protected]> wrote:

> kiako wrote, in part:
> > I oppose LLMs in Agora. I've got some personal opinions about their
> > capabilities (or lack thereof), but I'd rather like to focus on the
> > specific issues of automated text output in Agora.
> >
> > Using an LLM is an inherently antisocial behavior, which does not
> > mesh well with an intrinsically social game. The only value of an
> > LLM, as currently marketed and as primarily used, is
> >
> >   * to avoid reading text produced by humans,
> >   * to avoid writing text needing to be read by humans,
> >   * to avoid learning/practicing skills, and, in general,
> >   * to avoid communicating with humans.
> >
> > The purpose of an "agentic" LLM in Agora is to "play" the game without
> > having to engage personally with the game, at the cost of the other
> > participants' investments. I can marginally tolerate one "agentic" LLM
> > - it is sometimes interesting to see where it fails - but I lose
> > interest once two LLMs generate messages towards each other. Agora
> > runs by the voluntary efforts of our (absolutely wonderful <3)
> > officers, so actions performed between LLMs are actions initiated by
> > no one, for the benefit of no one, that must be tracked by someone.
> >
> > The alternative is having LLMs generate reports, which, given their
> >  propensity for errors, just kicks the can down the line to those
> > reviewing and CoE'ing.
> >
> > As a recent observation, we have a general (and quite important)
> > cultural practice of pointing out newer players' errors before those
> > errors can bite them. When an LLM generates text with errors, it's
> > created busywork for humans with no guarantee that future output will
> > ever improve. For me, this is incentive to not bother noting errors
> > I've caught, creating a more hostile culture for newer players to have
> > to suffer through. I'd rather Agora appear (and continue to be)
> > friendly and welcoming towards all active participants.
>
> kiako's points make a lot of sense to me, and I want to add my voice in
> support fwiw.  My objection to the use of AI isn't really about whether
> a language model can produce a coherent proposal or CFJ argument.  Let's
> even suppose it can, without error.  Still, what gets displaced when a
> participant lets software stand in for eir own engagement?  The life of
> the game.  If 4st has a blot, I revoke it, paying the fee to do so,
> which is seven spendies.  This game works best because people, thinking
> humans, are actually present in it: reading what others have written,
> weighing arguments, building on precedent, and taking responsibility for
> their own actions.  A model that acts on someone's behalf hollows out
> that presence even when the output looks fine on the surface.  Plus, the
> other points kiako made are important also, such as the volunteer-labor
> issue.
>
> Yours,
>
> msh210
>

Reply via email to