> Date: Tue, 30 May 2017 20:27:19 +0200 > From: Xavi Ivars <[email protected]> > To: [email protected], > apertium-stuff <[email protected]> > Reply-To: [email protected] > Subject: [Apertium-stuff] Toponims and gender/number in (some) monolingual > dictionaries > Pièce(s) jointes(s) probable(s)> > Hi all, > > As part of the GSoC work Marc is doing for eng-cat, we found out something > that was previously identified by Hèctor when working on the fra-cat: the > Catalan monodix (and many other "big" monodixes, like the Spanish one) > don't have gender and number information for toponyms. On top of that, > they're tagged (for historical reasons) as "loc", instead of top. > > That makes it harder to properly translate to other languages like French, > or from other languages, like English: "França és un estat" should get > translated as "*La* France est un État", where *La *is the feminine > singular article, but that forces adding all the morphological information > into the bidix. Similarly, "The United States" should be translated into > Catalan as "*Els* Estats Units", where *Els* is the masculine plural one. > > Changing this in Catalan (and probably also Spanish) would probably require > quite a lot of work to make sure all language pairs that use those > monolingual packages. That's the reason why, with Hèctor, we decided to do > that work in the fra-cat bilingual dictionary instead. But I've seen it has > also been added to the spa-ita monolingual, just to not to touch > apertium-spa. And if we want good eng-cat translations, it'll need to be > added to the eng-cat monolingual as well. > > After discussing it with Marc and Mikel, and also based on previous > conversations with Hèctor, seems pretty clear that, in the long term, the > best option will be update the monolingual dictionaries and propagate the > changes to all other language pairs that require it. But that may be quite > a lot of work in the short term. > > So the questions here would be: > > - Is there any "easy" way to estimate the work that will need to be done > to adapt apertium-cat (and apertium-spa) dependent pairs? (I'm not even > sure what are the "dependent" packages...) > - Is there anyone opposed to us applying the changes to apertium-cat? > - Can you think of a smaller increment for this change, so we can have > "slightly different" monodixes (even if it's just at build time) so we are > not forced to propagate the changes immediately if we want to avoid all > dependent packages to break? > > Thanks! > > -- > < Xavi Ivars > > < http://xavi.ivars.me >
Well, I think when a new bidix is built, for gender (and number), there is a simple way to bild it : - same gender in the two languages => no gender in the bidix - gender in one language, no gender for the other => gender on one side in the bidix - a different gender for the two languages => correct gender on each side of the bidix - in one language, the same lemma has one meaning for masculine, another for feminine => two entries with genders in the bidix. So, when building a new bidix, genders in monodicices may be used to build the bidix. And if a gender is missing in a monodix, it may be easily forgotten in the bidix. On the other side, if a gender is in the bidix, this gender should be accepted for generation. So, it should be in the monodix. I don't think to work on apertium-cat, but for apertium-fra, if it is presently only used by apertium-fra-cat pair, it could be a good idea to add these genders and numbers, even if other changes will have to be done to make this bidix working with at least apertiun-fra-por and apertium-epo-fra pairs when it will be time to release them. -------------------------------- Bernard Chardonneau (France) Phone : [33] 9 72 36 32 90 GSM phone : [33] 7 69 46 16 31 Multilingual websites for my free softwares : http://libremail.free.fr and http://libremail.tuxfamily.org http://cyloop.tuxfamily.org (mainly translated with Apertium) My general website (in french only) http://bech.free.fr ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Check out the vibrant tech community on one of the world's most engaging tech sites, Slashdot.org! http://sdm.link/slashdot _______________________________________________ Apertium-stuff mailing list [email protected] https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/apertium-stuff
