--- fabio guillermo rojas
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
"It's well documented that long term memory is nil for
children less than five years of age (doctors call it
"pediatric amnesia")...."

The Hippacampus isn't fully developed, and it's the
organ of the brain responsible for transferring short
term memories into long term memories.  It is well
documented that adults with hippacampal lesions cannot
put memories into long term storage.  

The brain goes through alot of development and fine
tuning up through adolescense, and the formative years
are when all the major pathways are solidified. 
Additionally, it's also the time when all the unused
neurons die; the only time more neurons die than in
early childhood is at death.  

Still, it nevertheless seems odd to address the
question to children's non-cooperation--Mr. Hanson's
post notwithstanding.  Cooperation as we think of it
here in the west is not really a species wide
phenomenon; i.e. it's probably not instictive.  As I
understand it, about 40% of adult male Yanomami have
killed another person and about 25% of adult males
will die from some form of violence.  That's hardly
the sort of peacful social cooperation that this
string seems to assume.  In some cultures it is
considered kosher to hide in wait and actually hunt
people.

While I WOULD be interested to see how child
cooperative behavior compares between modern societies
and hunter-gatherer societies, as Mr. Hanson
suggested, it still seems a bit unreasonable to
suggest that adult cooperative behavior as we
understand it is the standard against which the
strangeness of child behavior should be guaged. 
Rather one should ask:
1. Is child social behavior more stereotyped across
the species?  And if so
2. Why does adult behavior develop the way it does in
so many different forms?  Or possibly 
3. If child social behavior not stereotyped across the
species, what accounts for the differences.

Thanks for your time,
jsh



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Sign up for SBC Yahoo! Dial - First Month Free
http://sbc.yahoo.com

Reply via email to