Here are my answers to questions by Kaushik Barua: And what exactly do you mean by "Alternative Analysis"??
"A second analysis that will exclude any objectionable stuff found in the first analysis, but will at least include likely answers to the questions I asked (see below) in my previous email." Just because he belongs to a particular caste/community, is it justified to accept the verdict or so-called analytical "conclusion" that he is willfully discriminating against the other communities?. Can you tell me how we are ADDING VALUE by doing this? "Sorry but I do not see these questions relevant, since in the first analysis the author defined OBC equals Other Backward Class." Or is Class same as Caste? Thanks, Ranendra Das Kaushik Barua <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Yes, Mr Ranendra Das, you are correct in saying that I am NOT endorsing or covering up the actions of the CM or the so-called police officer. Because my sole intention was to simply convey that "we should try and use this online group/forum for sharing and exchanging constructive ideas and information, which should ADD VALUE, like you yourself so gloriously emphasised in your mail, instead of using it as a platform for expounding/propagating news and analysis based on the premises of caste, community, creed etc that might further divide our society which is already in the throes of such violence and turmoil". Yes, if the CM is not dispensing his duties appropiately and innocent people are suffering due to this, then definitely the public has the right to raise valid questions. Yes, indeed people should raise their voice and make the concerned persons answerable. But is it justified to bring the caste-community angle to his actions (or lack of it, like it has been alleged)?? Just because he belongs to a particular caste/community, is it justified to accept the verdict or so-called analytical "conclusion" that he is willfully discriminating against the other communities?. Can you tell me how we are ADDING VALUE by doing this? And what exactly do you mean by "Alternative Analysis"?? Best Regards, Kaushik Barua ----- Original Message ---- From: ranendra <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: [email protected] Sent: Saturday, June 16, 2007 7:11:23 AM Subject: [asom] Re: Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi: non-Ahom native-Assamese & Kamrupi murders Let us say that Kaushik Barua's purpose of writing is "not to cover up CM Gogoi and police officer Patangia thru his writing". Then it would be interesting to know what Kaushik Barua has to say about: 1. why CM Gogoi ordered a judicial probe within 12 hours after gunning down the two Geleki Gogois? 2. why CM Gogoi needed 9 days to order a judicial probe for Budheswar Moran? 3. why CM Gogoi did not (or yet to) order judicial probes for Vaishnavs' murderers under the jurisdiction of Garshuk PS, officer in-charge Mr. Patangia, though the first murder took place in January? My suggestion is that one should present an alternative analysis to counter an analysis, because that way it adds value. Note that if CM Gogoi would have ordered a judicial probe for the first Vaishnav murder under the jurisdiction of police officer Patangia in January, the most recent murders of the other 2 Vaishanav could have been prevented. Similarly, there would not have been 8 more deaths after Moran. Thanks, Ranendra Das --- Kaushik Barua <ikaushik.barua@ ...> wrote: How ridiculous and cheap this kind of analysis appears in this age of globalization, when people are transcending the barriers of caste, religion and nationality. Even though this is a democratic country and everyone has the right to express their own views/perspectives, this kind of analysis/justifications based on caste, creed and regionalism should be severely condemned and discouraged, as this will initiate nothing else but further hatred and division of our society. Best Regards, Kaushik Barua rabindeka <[EMAIL PROTECTED] com> wrote: Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi: non-Ahom native-Assamese & Kamrupi murders in Assam In Geleki Sivsagar when CISF jawans gunned down 2 youths Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi has ordered a judicial probe into the incident within less than 12 hours of the death. Here the two local youths gunned down were Nilikesh Gogoi and Bhulu Gogoi. see link http://www.assamtribune.com/scripts/details.asp?id=jan2507/at02 to see how the killer has been taken to Sivsagar Court: http://www.assamtribune.com/jan3007/photo.html While the Jammu and Kashmir Rifles making him a fake-ulfa murdered the twenty-four- year-old Tea Garden Night Watch Man Buddheswar Moran on May 5, the same Chief Minister of Assam Tarun Gogoi had not ordered a judicial probe into the incident within less than 12 hours. Instead he waited and continued to watch more deaths - at least eight deaths were reported during the protest. The Chief Minister has ordered a judicial probe to the murder of Buddheswar Moran on May 14. This was 9 days apart, as opposed to 12 hours in case of Geleki's Gogois see link http://www.assamtribune.com/scripts/details. asp?id=may1507/at09 Ahom history reveals that Ahom rulers discriminated/ punished Moran people. Two examples of Kamrupi murders Tarun Gogoi yet to order judicial probes: 1. In January Assam Police picked a Vaishnav boy (Sarma, a bipra boy, Narayani Vaishnav) from Mazkhowa while came to Guwanati from Tangal (greater Kamrupi land) to buy stuff for his Gelamaal Dokaan. Then the police (Garshuk police station, near Mazkhowa) let him go near Nepali Pahar and then shot him to death - Assam Police made him a fake-ulfa. 2. Most recent after Guwahati bomb blast, Assam Police took off two Vaishnav boys from a bus and shot to death once again near Garshuk police station - here too Assam Police made both of them fake-ulfa. They were both from Shimla (greater Kamrupi land) and were day labour in Guwahati. Current Garshuk Polis Station Officer Incharge is a Ahom (Patangia) man as well. * Is Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi a icon of Ahom ruler that he must discriminate and watch more deaths if victims were not Ahom? * Or is Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi abusing Ahom Wisdom? * Or is Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi availing OBC quota here? * Can people forgive ISI Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi ? Abbreviation: OBC - Other Backward Class ISI - Inconsistently- low-morale native-asSamese Individual CM - Chief Minister It appears as if OBC ISI Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi prioritizes Ahom population of Assam and protects them.
