On Tuesday, November 9, 2004, at 01:35 PM, Tim Bray wrote:

Removed superfluous "MUST be a string" language per Martin D�rst.

Dropped the use of xml:base to force the base URI for rel= per suggestion from Roundy, D�rst, et al.

Revised the abstract per Ayers.

 http://www.intertwingly.net/wiki/pie/PaceFieldingLinks

If we can accept the Pace and then argue whether to add more values to the initial list, then this looks like a good step forward. As difficult as the link discussion has been, any step forward may be worth taking, even if it's small.

One addition that might be helpful in avoiding misunderstandings: After "the base URI...", clarify with an additional sentence along the lines of "Unregistered values MUST be Absolute URIs, and MUST NOT point to any location beneath 'http://www.iana.org/assignments/TBD/'." Obvious? Perhaps. But a careless or uninformed reading (someone who doesn't realize that the base URI is only applied to non-absolute URIs) could miss the fact that one can use unregistered values.



Reply via email to