Thomas Broyer wrote:
Furthermore, can someone point out which RFC or I-D defines link
rel="first", link rel="last", link rel="next" and link rel="previous"?

http://www.iana.org/assignments/link-relations.html says its Feed History.

I've been meaning to ask about that. When those link relations were first defined, I thought the idea was that they would be fairly generic so that they could be used in various situations. The link definitions themselves make no reference to things like sort order or the stability of the documents to which they point. That should be up to the spec that uses them - for example AtomPub partial lists are typically ordered by app:edited, but feed history paged feeds make no recommendation either way.

However, having the IANA registration point to the feed history draft implies things about those relations which were never intended. IMHO that's a bad thing. The feed history draft describes one possible use of those links, but certainly not the only one. There should be no obligation for other specs to be semantically identical in their usage.

Regards
James

Reply via email to