Antone Roundy wrote:
Bill de hOra wrote:
Daniel Aleksandersen wrote:
But when it comes to atom archiving, it gets a little trickier….
Should I use the same ISSN as for my recent updates feed? The idea of
ISSN is that it should uniquely identify all issues of a serial
publication. So it would be appropriate to use it in the static feed
archives as well as in the continuously update feed. It is not
globally unique on a per my feed basis; but it is globally unique on
a per…me…basis. If that made any sense to anyone?
Yes, it made sense. Give the two feeds different ids.
But Bill, it's not two different feeds, it's two different views of the
same feed -- an archive view, and a "latest entries" (a.k.a. "sliding
window") view. Thus the shared atom:id IS "globally unique on a per my
feed basis", just not on a per feed DOCUMENT basis.
What breaks if they have two different ids?
Put another way, why are two URLs required, but only one id? Are views
(for any definition of "view") really a special case?
cheers
Bill
