Thank you. I will continue my reviews
On Tue, Nov 10, 2009 at 11:59 AM, Jean Hollis Weber <[email protected]>wrote: > Emma Kirsopp wrote: > >> Just curious as to how the feedback process works here in regard to >> reviewing and proofreading. >> > > After someone reviews a chapter, the person responsible for that chapter > goes through the review, accepts or rejects the reviewer's tracked changes, > and revises any material that needs rewriting in response to the reviewer's > comments. The responsible person then resubmits the chapter for further > review, or publishes it, depending on its state of development and the > extent of the changes made. > > (Aside: In theory, the responsible person is the primary author of the > chapter, but in practice it's usually me or Michele Zarri, because a lot of > the original authors are no longer active.) > > I try to give feedback to new reviewers, regarding what they did right or > wrong (IMO), but I confess that I don't always do that because I get > distracted by other work and forget. > > BTW, I haven't yet got to checking your review of that particular chapter. > So many chapters, so little time! ;-) > > --Jean >
