At 09:32  -0400 2006/06/03, Brian Schott wrote:
        First the good news: I have found the way to get
some of these Mac-centric keystroke shortcuts to work now.

        Now some not so good news:
  .....
        There does NOT appear any way to make command+w
close a window.


Brian,

Thank you for your experiments and observations.

I hadn't thought to mention before, but I really appreciate that
Cmd-q quits j (without the pesky "Do you want to close?" message).
I assume that Roger uses something like Alt+F4 to quit, since he
has long been an outspoken critic of "Are you sure?" style
messages....

About the Fx keys, I think they are more tricky to deal with
and already have definitions (at least the upper ones) in OS X
that are useful and supply some of the things that are in J
menu items (like F10 displaying all the windows of the current
active application and F9 showing all visible windows). It is
nice that F1 and Shift+F1 behave as advertised, but too bad about
Cntrl+F1 not working...

I think these issues may be amongst those that are impossible
to "solve correctly" - I was dismayed several releases ago when
MS removed a bunch of shortcut keys from Excel. Actually, the
only one that I was a big fan of was Command+D/R for "paste
down/right" in selected cells. I think it was probably their
answer to the kind of complaints we are hearing here.

I look forward to more exploration into ways that a user can
set things up the way she wants them (and not have to do all
the work over again in the next release...)

- joey
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For information about J forums see http://www.jsoftware.com/forums.htm

Reply via email to