On Apr 14, 2014, at 10:09, Colin A. Smith wrote:
> On Apr 13, 2014, at 22:54, Christiaan Hofman <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> On Apr 13, 2014, at 19:51, Colin A. Smith wrote:
>>
>>> The point of view is more clear you preserve the order of the elements in
>>> the search query and make a sentence by prepending "Show me articles":
>>>
>>> Show me articles CITED BY WOS:XXXXX
>>> Show me articles CITING WOS:XXXXX
>>>
>>> Perhaps there’s a way to preserve the order of the elements and make a
>>> sentence that implies the other point of view, but I don’t think that’s
>>> possible without adding intervening words. The equals sign does make things
>>> more ambiguous, because there aren’t nouns, like “PARENT” or “CHILD”, that
>>> describe relationships between papers without conjugation or prepositions.
>>
>> Auch, that sounds like AppleScript. And that's a horror, we should not come
>> close to this. The point is not to write sensible questions. the point is to
>> efficiently write search terms. This is something that you potential do a
>> lot. That's why being succinct is not just good, but really important. It's
>> exactly why the old form is so very bad. The other search terms are also not
>> like "AUTHOR=xxx", but "AU=xxx". It has to be unambiguous (in terms of the
>> definitions), not necessarily all sensible English.
>
> I totally agree that we should not be trying to be like AppleScript. I think
> AppleScript goes wrong because its syntax is too much like English sentence
> fragments and not nearly enough structured shorthand. I do however believe
> that most people codify their ideas in (in)complete sentences. "SO=Science"
> can easily be transcribed into “source equals Science”, which makes it
> mentally easier to go in the reverse direction.
>
>>>> I don't get this confusion when I think of it in terms of "references" and
>>>> "citations". And "ref" and "cit" are actually very common shorthands for
>>>> those terms.
>>>
>>>
>>> You might hate the idea, but one way to resolve this would be to have two
>>> terms for each operation, REF/CITEDBY for citedReferences and CIT/CITING
>>> for citingArticles.
>>>
>>> Cheers,
>>>
>>> Colin
>>
>>
>> I think that's unnecessary, it only confuses things. Why remember two
>> things, when one is sufficient? the thing I like about REF and CIT is not
>> that they so much that they are super clear, I think that's not so
>> irrelevant, but rather that they're distinct and succinct, so efficient. For
>> instance I think CITEDBY and CITING look too much alike, so they get more
>> easily confused, and that's bad for its purpose. In the end you just have to
>> remember what the term is anyway, so better have a clear difference. the
>> actual meaning is not so important, what is important is that you can attach
>> some meaning to it, just to remember it.
>
> Again, it would be very helpful if you could further explain the actual
> meaning that you are attaching to the terms REF (reference) and CIT
> (citation), because I don’t follow you there.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Colin
Again, the main point is that they are used for searching. That's a repeating
action, not a one-time setting. Therefore being short is the most important
aspect, and not being really clear in the meaning (that may only be relevant
the first few times you use it.) Then you make a connection to these terms in
your brain, and use it from then on. For this, it is actually good if they are
distinct, rather than looking similar (like CITING and CITED). Now, maybe you
can get different and opposite meanings from both CIT and REF, but I already
argued that can be said for really any term you make here. So giving up on
short and concise to to try being more clear buys you exactly nothing but costs
a lot (every time you have to type these few more characters.) From that pov I
think CIT and REF look really good. Again, it is not the most important thing
that they really have unambiguous meaning. It is more relevant if you can make
a clear association in your brain,. just to remember which is which. I have
really no problem with that. For me, citations of an article are the ones that
cite the article (citingArticles). And reference of an articles are the ones
that it refers to, i.e. the bibliography (citedReferences.) I thought these
were pretty standard meanings. I am not saying you can change formulations such
that these terms may mean the opposite, but that's not what's relevant.
Christiaan
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Learn Graph Databases - Download FREE O'Reilly Book
"Graph Databases" is the definitive new guide to graph databases and their
applications. Written by three acclaimed leaders in the field,
this first edition is now available. Download your free book today!
http://p.sf.net/sfu/NeoTech
_______________________________________________
Bibdesk-develop mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bibdesk-develop