[Please answer to <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> it is off-topic here.]

On Sat, Mar 20, 2004 at 03:31:19PM -0500, Nathan J. Mehl wrote:
> In the immortal words of Thomas Schwinge ([EMAIL PROTECTED]):
> > 
> > So, what about switching to DJB's /package installation hierarchy
> > <URL:http://cr.yp.to/slashpackage.html> 
> 
> Aieee, no.  Please, let me be the first of probably many to say:
> please don't use slashpackage.  It's a constricting (and annoying)
> solution to a problem that no one has.

To "problem that no one has":
<URL:http://cr.yp.to/slashpackage/studies.html>
Doing a quick search on bincimap I found this:
<URL:http://news.gmane.org/find-root.php?group=gmane.mail.imap.binc.general&article=2022>

To "constricting":
I'd rather call it consequent and well thought-out than "constricting".
 
What is your method of having both a stable version (for production use)
and a development version (for testing new features) of e.g. bincimap
running at the same time?

> And as an amusing side-note, while djb adores slashpackage so much
> that he was willing to see daemontools dropped from the openbsd ports
> system rather than de-link it from slashpackage

IMHO you don't need it in the ports if it is easily installable using
the source code.

> he apparently doesn't
> like it enough to actually issue versions of any of his other software
> (qmail, djbdns, ucspi-tcp, etc) that use it

I'm quite sure he said to release new versions conforming to
slashpackage someday but I can't find the relevant post at the moment.

> and if you try to
> distribute pre-built versions of them converted into slashpackage
> format, he'll sue you.

Again: There is no need to distribute pre-built packages. It's so easily
installable using the source code.

> (And no, I'm not trying to start another djb flameware: I use lots of
> his software quite happily.  I just think slashpackage is daft.)

I thought the same when I first saw it and started installing his
software into FHS's paths - now I have my whole system based on
slash-package (using slashpackage-foreign
<URL:http://multivac.cwru.edu./spf/> for 'traditional' packages).
Things got a lot easier since the switch.


Regards,
 Thomas

Reply via email to