I'm not sure how bip102 is less secure than other blocksize proposal but please let's keep defects specific to each proposal in their own threads. In any case, I understand that you agree that 95% confirmation is a good idea for uncontroversial hardforks (like in uncontroversial softforks). I'm not sure if you prefer that to happen before or after the time threshold, but I guess you're fine with doing it after the threshold since you didn't complained about that specifically (you can always clarify your preferences of course).
On Tue, Aug 4, 2015 at 11:29 PM, Peter Todd <[email protected]> wrote: > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- > Hash: SHA256 > > > > On 4 August 2015 16:02:53 GMT-04:00, "Jorge Timón via bitcoin-dev" > <[email protected]> wrote: >>One thing I've noticed there seems to be disagreement on is whether >>miners' upgrade confirmation (aka voting) is necessary for >>uncontroversial hardforks or not. > > To be clear, without a strong supermajority of miner support the fork risks > attack. Requiring 95% approval - which is actually just a 50% majority vote > as the majority can squelch the minority - is an obvious minimum safety > requirement. > > Another option is Hearn's proposal of using centralised checkpoints to > override PoW consensus; obviously that raises serious questions, including > legal issues. > > For forks without miner approval miners have a number of options to defeat > them. For instance, they can make their own fork with a new consensus > algorithm that requires miners to prove they're attacking the unwanted chain > - Garzik's recent 2MB blocks proposal is a hilarious, and probably > accidental, example of such a design, with the original Bitcoin protocol > rules having the effect of attacking the Garzik 2MB chain. > > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- > > iQE9BAEBCAAnIBxQZXRlciBUb2RkIDxwZXRlQHBldGVydG9kZC5vcmc+BQJVwS7F > AAoJEMCF8hzn9Lnc47AH/3926JLE4Rn9Fil+wvfxhfmBqIm0wtfStPDAqsQMDIbh > kbxOw/Mai/AbqNUkYUWvoM2ZfJ/JNkA6HA977CE6huT1ozYVz8TJQmcqN/p1QXfX > w1559UsXXop2fepY1dbnyBUwB6w6VwBrfj3awYkJsblgcdHrEsAesYeAHphAkwL/ > kxQ0b+QmttaDCSK76hNloKVcN7AczdCSw1pux2rzmsG9zkwWJrIqR/prAO1nuk9Y > LgQUCvYkZiMmMD8kNx9ZVRG2Y951uLS6594Qy6ZoAMAdA6QxNsP4qyE7s8M2HAon > WjdS0UqTRyJuDVqpNav6WX4jTllK/UuHRUAOmBmYaRs= > =0cKq > -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- > _______________________________________________ bitcoin-dev mailing list [email protected] https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/bitcoin-dev
