On Tue, 30 Jan 2001, Darryl Shannon wrote:

> One more thing.  You keep saying that the US is not a democracy.  If
> you don't stop saying that you run the risk of people deciding you are
> an idiot.  We are a democracy.  You may have some ideas to improve our
> political process, perhaps we might even agree on some of them.  But
> flatly stating that the US is not a democracy stretches the meanings
> of words past their breaking point.  Engaging in hyperbole like this
> is not helpful.  It's like claiming that your mother is an abusive
> parent when she won't let you go to the show you wanted.  Yes, perhaps
> she made a poor decision, but calling her abusive merely weakens your
> arguments.

Er, we're NOT a democracy -- we're a representative republic.  THAT much I
remember from my high school American history class in 11th grade.  Now,
we may have some governmental structures at lower levels that *are*
democracies; I think that the Town Meeting form of government as practiced
by a number of smaller towns in New England count as that, and that's
something I've actually participated in -- and it's nothing like, say, a
presidential election.

If you declare that we're a democracy, you run the risk of people deciding
you don't quite have a grasp on what you're talking about.  ;)

        Julia


Reply via email to