Hi,

    all the errors go into B and so you can get decent R with wrong
    structure. Glycosylated proteins have a large component totally
    disordered - do you see any sugars?
    with B~133 you uj is 3.7A which means that atom is all over the
    place and meaningless
    As a reviewer I would certainly question the interpretation of
    such structure.
    If the data collection was at 100K (or any cryo condition) one
    expects B~20 for a good structure


I wouldn't interpret it that literally. The distribution of mean B-factors computed for structures in PDB at resolutions between 2.8 and 3..2A is: Mean B-factor value Number of structures in PDB
    1.000 - 21.000     : 137
   21.000 - 41.000     : 430
   41.000 - 61.000     : 612
   61.000 - 81.000     : 390
   81.000 - 101.000    : 172
  101.000 - 121.000    : 36
  121.000 - 141.000    : 12
  141.000 - 161.000    : 8
  161.000 - 181.000    : 0
  181.000 - 201.000    : 1

There is good amount of models with mean B-factors well higher than 70. I doubt that PDB would accept a structure where atoms are "all over the place" -:) And I wouldn't claim that those models are all bad simply because they don't have B-factors~20. There is a number of publications that discuss this and show similar histograms, so there is no point to repeat it.

So, Jiamu, *if* the high B-factors is the only issue with this part of your structure, then make sure that the domain in question is properly modeled, and keep the above histogram just in case should you run into a picky reviewer -:)

Pavel.

PS>
Same histogram as above, but computed for all models in resolution range from 3 to 4A: Mean B-factor value Number of structures in PDB
    0.000 - 22.720     : 90
   22.720 - 45.440     : 250
   45.440 - 68.160     : 295
   68.160 - 90.880     : 271
   90.880 - 113.600    : 131
  113.600 - 136.320    : 73
  136.320 - 159.040    : 32
  159.040 - 181.760    : 13
  181.760 - 204.480    : 8
  204.480 - 227.200    : 5

and finally, for high resolution models in 0.0 to 1.0A:
Mean B-factor value Number of structures in PDB
    1.800 - 4.190      : 3
    4.190 - 6.580      : 4
    6.580 - 8.970      : 18
    8.970 - 11.360     : 41
   11.360 - 13.750     : 50
   13.750 - 16.140     : 34
   16.140 - 18.530     : 9
   18.530 - 20.920     : 3
   20.920 - 23.310     : 3
   23.310 - 25.700     : 5




Reply via email to