Hassan Schroeder wrote:

Geoff Deering wrote:

So what is the problem with documents in OASIS ODF?

Given that folks are probably tired of this discussion, I'll just
say that ODF is an XML description of a document (including style),
which offers no hint as to the semantics of the *content* of that
document. It's completely orthogonal to the kind of content (data)
granularity I'm talking about.


If I may say so, I think a lot of XML professionals would be surprised to see ODF defined as you have done above.


Just to take your example of granularity;

<author>
 <givenName/>
 <middleInitial/>
 <surName/>
</author>



In ODF;

<define name="paragraph-content" combine="choice">
        <element name="text:author-name">
                <ref name="common-field-fixed-attlist"/>
                <text/>
        </element>
</define>

<define name="paragraph-content" combine="choice">
        <element name="text:author-initials">
                <ref name="common-field-fixed-attlist"/>
                <text/>
        </element>
</define>


---------------
Geoff Deering
*********************************************************
The CMS discussion list for http://webstandardsgroup.org/
*********************************************************

Reply via email to