Geoff Deering wrote:

> Can you please define "granular content" for me, and how it's collected?

<author>
  <givenName/>
  <middleInitial/>
  <surName/>
</author>

That's granular; saying "This book was written by Joe W. Blow"
is not -- how does a machine pick the "author" out of that?

And you collect it with forms, like any other data.

> I think, in general, if you are customising scripts within an
> application, and they are designed for that, then that is fine.  But in
> apps like IWTS you have to write many scripts in their Perl derivative
> to get it to clean up a lot of stuff.  If you are having to write any
> new transformations that aren't part of the core app, that to me is
> having to reinvent the wheel (to a very small extent).  But I'm more
> referring to having to write all these scripts to tie transformations
> between applications together.

Now I'm not sure what you mean by "transformations between
applications".

> Can you clarify your definition of content and document.

In Web terms, "content" is what's in each (non-presentational!)
element of a page: <p>, <cite>, <address>, etc. The "document"
is the page as a whole.

> Can you please also explain your definition of  "You *build* documents
> to specific targets *from* granular content"?

Sure; you can take, say:

<product>
  <product_number/>
  <product_line/>
  <short_description/>
  <long_description/>
  <long_description_dripping_with_marketing_gibberish/>
</product>

:: and create a document for a specific purpose from 1 or more
of those elements.

> What is your definition of "semantically structured"?

Headings, logical divisions -- anything that shows up in Word's
"outline" (I think it's called) panel.

>> Sorry, I don't see it. There are "document management systems" and
>> "content management systems" -- they're not the same... :-)
> 
> They might not be the same, so what distinguishes them?  Can you please
> give clear definitions?

A "document management system" manages documents as black-box objects;
in a CMS each element is an independent object.

-- 
Hassan Schroeder ----------------------------- [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Webtuitive Design ===  (+1) 408-938-0567   === http://webtuitive.com

                          dream.  code.


*********************************************************
The CMS discussion list for http://webstandardsgroup.org/
*********************************************************

Reply via email to