Morrison, John wrote:
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: Giacomo Pati [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]
>>Sent: Wednesday, 05 September 2001 7:39 am
>>To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>Subject: Re: AW: [C2][VOTE] Sync C2.0 and C2.1 branches
>>
>>
>>Quoting Carsten Ziegeler <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>:
>>
>>
>>>Many thanks for this research, dims!
>>>
>>>
>>>>Davanum Srinivas wrote:
>>>>
>>>>Team,
>>>>
>>>>Here are the "significant" differences. Please go ahead and add
>>>>your +1/-1/0 to each item. If i
>>>>have missed anything, please add it to the bottom of the list
>>>>with your vote.
>>>>
>>>> 1) XML:DB Generators - There are two generators in C2.1 for
>>>>dealing with data from XML:DB data
>>>>sources
>>>>
>>>+0 (These are additional components which do not affect the core)
>>>
>>+0 as well. Yes, they don't affect the core. But as it is an
>>XML stream comming
>>from an xmldb what about making it a protocl
>>(dbxml:/db/mydocs/foo[is='bar'])?
>>
>
> +0
>
+0. BTW, Source is better than URLFactory since it this is natively XML
(URLs must go through a parser)
>>>> 2) FOP Serializers / Renderer Components - C2.1 has a
>>>>configurable, SAX based Serializer that
>>>>supports PCL, PS and PDF.
>>>>
>>>+1 (I tend to think that the FOP serializer belongs to the core)
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1 This shouldn't impact anyone currently using 2.0
>
>
+1 : Dynamic PDF is a major cocoon feature.
>>>> 3) JUnit based Test cases - C2.1 has a framework for test cases
>>>>from Stuart
>>>>
>>>+0
>>>
>>+0
>>
>
> +0 Good for 2.1 - required for 2.0? Prob not.
>
>
+1 if they don't rely on 2.1-only classes (i.e. no specific port for 2.0)
>>>> 4) Source Interface changes - C2.1 has changes from Ovidiu for
>>>>better core implementation.
>>>>
>>>+5 (Important core changes)
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1 Best to try and keep the core in sync
>
>
+1 also
>>>> 5) LogKit mechanism - C2.1 has better support for log messages
>>>>from Giacomo
>>>>
>>>+5 (Great work from Giacomo)
>>>
>>+1, thanks :)
>>
>
> +1 Seconded!
+10 for this great feature, even if it requires a non-released Excalibur.
>>>> 6) Site WEBAPP - Separate Webapp for SITE from Donald Ball.
>>>>
>>>+0 to +1 (could make SITE maintanance a bit easier?)
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
+1
>>>> 7) SiteBuilder - Sitemap editor cocoon app contribution
>>>>
>>from Sergio
>>
>>>Haven't tested it yet.
>>>
>>-0. I still see it throwing exceptions.
>>
>
> I've not used this either
>
>
+0.
>>>> 8) Catalog Support - Entity Catalog support from David Crossley
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> Or this - but I can see why it's needed! (+1)
>
>
+1
>>>> 9) Better JSP Support - JspEngineImplWLS and
>>>>JSPEngineImplNamedDispatcherInclude from Bernhard
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+0
>>
>
> 0 - I don't use JSP
>
>
+1. JSP integration allows some smooth "rewamping" of existing apps.
>>>>10) Parent Component Manager Support - Specify a configurable
>>>>parent Component Manager from Leo
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1
>>>>11) XSLTProcessor + TRaX Transformer update - componentize TRaX
>>>>support from Ovidiu
>>>>
>>>+1 (core changes)
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1
>>>>12) Simple Profiler and related Event Pipelines - Profiler
>>>>Support from Vadim
>>>>
>>>+1 (could help in starting with C2)
>>>
>>+0. Don't know the stability of it.
>>
>
> +0 I need to look into this soon...
>
>
+0.
>>>>13) DatabaseSelectionAction.java
>>>>
>>>+0
>>>
>>+0 Didn't know this is in 2.1 only.
>>
>
> +0 Don't use...
>
>
+O don't use also
>>>>14) ScriptAction.java
>>>>
>>>+1 (simple writing of actions)
>>>
>>+1
>
> +0 Again, don't use.
>
+1
>>>>15) ServerPagesAction.java / action.xsl
>>>>
>>>+0
>>>
>>-0
>>
>
> +0 guess what...
>
>
+0 : more thinking is needed about an action MarkupLanguage.
>>>>16) IncludeCacheValidity.java and CachingCIncludeTransformer.java
>>>>
>>>-1 (it depends on to many internal assumptions right now)
>>>
>>+0 Don't know its state.
>>
>
> +0
>
>
+0 (don't know).
>>>>17) Updated AbstractMarkupLanguage.java, LogicSheet.java,
>>>>NamedLogicSheet.java.
>>>>
>>>If this affects core changes +1
>>>
> +1
>
> Agreed +1
>
>
+1 (change on LogicSheet is related to XSLTProcessor)
>>>>18) Slightly updated HttpRequest.java.
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1
>>>>19) Updated EnvironmentWrapper.java.
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1
>>>>20) Updated Directory/File Generator.java
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1
>>>>21) updated i18n Transformer.
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+5
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1
>>>>22) Trivial SOAP samples.
>>>>
>>>+1 (Examples, yes!)
>>>
>>+0
>>
>
> +0 I do think that it's xsl files ought to be moved from
docs/samples/soap
> though...
>
>
-0 : isn't Axis to young to be included in 2.0 ?
>>>>23) RoleFilterTransformer.java
>>>>
>>>What's this? I must have missed it.
>>>
>>+0
>>
>
> +0
>
>
+1. Useful sitemap component implementations are good, but I wonder if
we shouldn't create a "examples" or "optional" package (like in Ant) in
org.apache.cocoon to hold all those classes that aren't core.
>>>>24) CocoonTargetFactory.java
>>>>
>>>What's this? I must have missed it, too.
>>>
>>It's part of the move to the LogKit Management where you have
>>Factories for
>>different LogTargets. As Cocoon has a custom LogTarget
>>(CocoonLogTarget) I've
>>written the corresponding Factory for it. So here is no voting
>>needed/acceptable.
>>
>>
+1
>>>>25) XMLizable interface
>>>>
>>>+1
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1
>
>
+1 (goes with Source changes)
>>>>26) SEL taglib
>>>>
>>>+0
>>>
>>+0 What the hell is this. Must have missed it.
>>
>
> 0 Me too!
>
>
Seems it allows to select parts of an XSP depending on a sitemap
parameter. Torsten, can you give us some use cases ?
>>>>27) Action taglib
>>>>
>>>+0
>>>
>>+0
>>
> +0
>
>
+0 (used with ServerPagesAction)
>>>>28) More sub sitemap samples.
>>>>
>>>+5 (yes, examples!)
>>>
>>+1
>>
>
> +1 examples - the more the merrier :) Donald - you've had some prettily
> formatted documents on your site - what ever happened to them? Could
they
> be added too?
>
+1
>>Hey, Dims, your work in keeping track what is happening in
>>the code base is
>>great. many thanks.
>>
>
> Yeah - how did you find all these?
>
> J.
>
Thanks also. Just to know : did you perform a diff between the two
branches, or do you keep track of cvs-commits ?
--
Sylvain Wallez
Anyware Technologies - http://www.anyware-tech.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
