>> -It would be nice if by default rpmdrake would show software that is
>> installed. IMHO, there should be an options dialog, which has things
>> like "show installed software in searches".
>
>It's a good idea[1] but I still don't see how to integrate well
>an options dialog. I don't want to add a menubar nor a toolbar
>just for that. I was thinking I was going to show installed
>software as well in searches by default, I think it should be ok
>for beginners.

Yes it is a good idea... and not. If a new checkbox "search for installed
softwares" has to be added to an interface which is especially made for
installing software, it demonstrates there is a problem with the interface,
and reviewers will criticise it. Then why not making appear this button in
the uninstall rpmdrake too ? And I expect so many newbies on the
mandrakeexpert or mailing lists asking why there is such a button.

Why not doing a "browse packages" interface, independent from any
install/uninstall consideration, with all information we can find in the
install rpmdrake. And then depending on the fact the package is already
installed or not, there would be an install/remove button. You may even add
a filter "only show installed packages" and "only show non-installed
packages". I really don't see why this would be difficult for beginners.
Instead of having two rpmdrake icons in the MCC with a + and a - symbol, you
would have only one +/- that would do the job. I really cannot understand
why it would be more complicated for newbies. And IMO, it would be more
confusing to have one "show installed packages" checkbox that would make
them appear as a tree at the end of non-installed packages.

Eric


Reply via email to