Matthew> I agree with Steve. I've struggled to think of any examples that don't 
constitute
> the physical object acting as a carrier for a conceptual object.

Matthew and Steve, I think you've missed the point: 
I did not say I have a case with *only* a shortcut "aboutness" property from 
Physical, where a longcut path through Conceptual could not exist.
I said that often it's useful to use a shortcut, without having to create a 
longcut.

Can you give any example of a physical object having P62_depicts 
that would preclude the existence of a conceptual object (E36 Visual Item) 
having P138_represents towards the same target?
If you cannot, what is your justification for having P62_depicts, but not 
having the properties denoted "???" in my original email?


Reply via email to