>> I don?t begrudge 4.x its growing pains. It is a complex technological shift
>> with a lot of promise. What I find most troubling is the decision process
>> that led to the use of 4.2 for Juno distros. When the decision was made, it
>> was plainly evident that 4.2 wasn?t going to match 3.8 on any of the quality
>> metrics. IDE users might have been ok with quality drop if 4.2 delivered
>> compelling new functionality that you couldn?t get in 3.8, yet there is no
>> tangible functional delta. The value of 4.x platform is for RCP developers
>> and to certain limited extent for IDE plugin developers. Certainly not for
>> IDE users. The refreshed look-n-feel has been touted as a big end user
>> feature of 4.2, but the new look-n-feel itself has numerous issues that
>> leave it looking like an unfinished project.
>>
>>
>> Sadly, the user reaction that we?ve been seeing over the last several months
>> has been entirely predictable.
So the next question is what have we done to avoid this? To me this is
a failure of the eclipse community, at least the committer / release train
community.
It has indeed been predictable and we have even been warned about it
from the provider of the platform themselves. I distinctively remember a
message from McQ warning us all about the various staffing issues he had, and
that he had to make drastic choices. From that, what have we done? Did we pull
up resources to help? Did we even test? After all, if it sucks today, it must
have been even worst back then in March. Obviously we have not done our due
diligence, at least I know I did not.
Was Juno a good point in time to introducing such a change? I say YES.
Why? Because as the current situation shows us, ppl don't try things until they
are forced to do so and that should we have chosen to wait until Kepler then
the same discussion would have happen but in September 2013. And don't try the
argument that you would have tried it. After all eclipse 4.1 was released in
July 2011.
But more importantly than all this is the meta conclusion that the era
of being able to take the platform for granted is over and that we are all
going to have to pay more attention to it, roll up our sleeves and contribute.
Pascal
_______________________________________________
cross-project-issues-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/cross-project-issues-dev
