-Caveat Lector- from: http://saturn.vcu.edu/~dbromley/paper-satanismandanticultism.htm <A HREF="http://saturn.vcu.edu/~dbromley/paper-satanismandanticultism.htm">paper- satanismandanticultism </A> --[1]-- THE SOCIAL CONSTRUCTION OF SUBVERSIVE EVIL: THE CONTEMPORARY ANTI-CULT AND ANTI-SATANISM MOVEMENTS David G. Bromley Department of Sociology and Anthropology Virginia Commonwealth University Diana Gay Cutchin Department of Sociology and Anthropology Virginia Commonwealth University Forthcoming in Jo Freeman, Editor Social Movements Since the Sixties Rowman and Littlefield, 1999 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ The Social Construction of Subversive Evil: The Contemporary Anticult and Antisatanism Movements Recent decades have been punctuated by two major cases of subversion fears, initially by groups labelled "religious cults" (Bromley and Shupe 1981) and subsequently by "satanic cults" (Richardson, Best, and Bromley 1991). During the 1970s subversion fears centered on a cohort of new religious movements that emerged beginning in the late 1960s. A series of high-profile, violent incidents involving groups such as the Peoples Temple and Branch Davidians in the United States, Temple Solaire in Canada and Europe, and Aum Shinrikyo in Japan continued to fuel public disquiet over alternative religious groups through the 1980s and 1990s. As these fears of subversion by religious cults were beginning to wane somewhat, a new subversion episode riveted public attention on satanic cults. During the 1980s subversion fears erupted over a putative underground cult of practicing satanists believed to be responsible for coordinating a variety of nefarious activities, the most shocking of which was alleged ritual abuse and sacrifice of large numbers of infants. For two decades a succession of incidents -- ranging from the grisly multiple murders in Matamoros, Mexico to highly publicized cases of teenage suicide linked to the Dungeons and Dragons fantasy game to the charges of ritual abuse at the McMartin Preschool in California -- has raised the specter of satanic subversion. In each of these subversion episodes a countersubversion movement mobilized rapidly to identify and resist various groups within American society alleged to be the source of subversive activity. The objective of this chapter is an analysis of these two countersubversion movement ideologies as social dramas. Countersubversion ideologies postulate the existence of a subversive conspiracy directed at undermining a fundamental source of order within a society and attribute to the subversives transcendent (i.e., extraordinary or supernatural) power of some kind. By definition subversives are dedicated to destructive principles and practices. They specifically undermine normal, natural individual and group functioning. Countersubversion movements thus conceive of themselves as engaged in an epic confrontation between forces of good and evil. In this chapter we interpret countersubversion ideologies as a form of drama, a narrative portrayal of the struggle of good against evil. A useful point of departure in sociologically interpreting these radical belief systems is the virtual axiom in social science theory that the reality we inhabit as human beings is constructed on both cultural and social dimensions (Berger and Luckmann 1966). Sociological understandings of how humans create an ordered existence traditionally have tended to accentuate the social dimension of human organization, but recent scholarship has begun to reassert the co-equal importance of the cultural dimension. This new balance is gaining a prominent place in research in the area of social movements. The earlier emphasis on the organizational dimension of social movements, which led to a conception of belief systems as epiphenomonal, is now being counterbalanced by serious treatment of ideas through which social movement participants create systems of meaning that orient their individual and collective action. Snow and Benford (1992:136), two major architects of this perspective, describe the change in the following way: "We do not view social movements merely as carriers of extant ideas and meanings that stand in isomorphic relationship to structural arrangements and/or unanticipated events. Rather, we see movement organizations and actors as actively engaged in the production and maintenance of meaning for constituents, antagonists, and bystanders or observers." From this perspective the social and cultural elements of human organization are interrelated, but neither can be reduced to the other. It follows from the assertion that the reality that humans inhabit is socially constructed that the order (or disorder) we experience partially is of our own making. One of the most important ways in which we construct order and disorder culturally is through the production of narratives of various kinds through which we organize and interpret social reality to ourselves. To create social reality through the production of narratives, of course, means that we quite literally become actors in our own stories. When social order is imperilled, therefore, humans become involved in real-life dramas of our own making (Turner 1980). Social movements offer a particularly apt context for developing this perspective since movements constitute organized challenges to the prevailing social order. That is, extant and proposed visions of the social order are in conflict. Social movements are organizational actors in the dramas of human experience that form in response to crises of order in specific social locations. Countersubversion movements create a extraordinarily high order of drama indeed. The postulation of an organized conspiracy to undermine the very foundation of the social order by a group that possesses extraordinary powers constitutes one of the most powerful ways in which humans create a sense of impending chaos. The question to be addressed here is how such ideologies are fashioned, how it is that we symbolize such ultimate evil. Let us create context for this analysis by briefly describing the two subversion episodes. THE RELIGIOUS AND SATANIC CULT SUBVERSION EPISODES The Religious Cult Episode Beginning about 1970, intense opposition mobilized to a cohort of new religious movements such as the Unification Church, Hare Krishnas, and The Family (at the time named the Children of God), that initially were labeled "religious cults" and drew the most intense opposition. Founded on the assertion that they in fact are pseudo-religions, "cults" were denounced for using "brainwashing" or "coercive mind control," to secure and control members. Anticultists assert that the gurus who lead religious cults are driven by a thirst for political and economic power as evidenced by empire-building and a dictatorial leadership style. Individual followers were seen as vulnerable young adults. Anti-cultists claimed the "cults" successfully evaded legal controls by cloaking their organization and activity with the mantle of religion and by operating through a variety of apparently legitimate "front groups." As a result, the number, size, power, and wealth of these monolithic, ruthless, authoritarian groups has increased dramatically, making them a grave threat to the social order. Organized countermovement opposition to new religious movements coalesced soon after the first of these groups began recruiting young adults (Bromley and Shupe 1993; Shupe and Bromley 1980). There are several wings of the Anticult Movement; the secular wing, which is the focus of attention here, was formed and has largely been energized by family members of converts. The historical moment when new religious movements were most successful in attracting adherents was one of transition and tension for families and young adults. In recognition of the increasing importance of education for career success, parents began organizing family life around preparation for higher education opportunities. This necessitated granting autonomy to young adults while at the same time maintaining parental direction during this extended socialization process. For their part, young adults found themselves caught between adolescence and adulthood; this tension was dramatically elevated by the sociopolitical conflicts of the 1960s and 1970s that yielded a range of protest and countercultural activity centered in the young adult population. The effect of conversions to new religious movements was to construct a niche that neutralized the control systems of both family and educational systems. Further, these movements not only rejected the dominant forms of social relations, they sacralized their antithesis by supplanting family relationships and secular careers with collectivist relationships and spiritual careers. Families of converts, initially mystified at the rebellion of their offspring, soon began to interpret these radical departures as a conspiracy by cultic groups to subvert the free will of their offspring. The families that organized the Anticult Movement subsequently were joined by mainline churches, opposing what they regard as doctrinal heresy, a minority group within the mental health community, for whom counseling exiting members of these movements became a practitioner specialty, and some governmental agencies, over practices deemed inappropriate to a religious organization. The most novel feature of the anticult campaign is the practice of "deprogramming." Assuming that adherents are brainwashed, the Anticult Movement developed a procedure designed to reverse the effects of cultic mind control through "de-programming." In its initial form, deprogramming involved abduction and physical restraint of new religious movement members until they agreed to renounce their religious affiliations (Bromley 1988). A network of entrepreneurial deprogrammers emerged who offered their services to families, based on assertions that they possessed special knowledge of techniques for reversing brainwashing effects. An increase in the number of deprogrammings and growing resistance to them resulted in anticult sponsored legislative initiatives in numerous states to legalize deprogramming under mental health codes. Although none of these initiatives ultimately was successful, the Anticult Movement has achieved a moderate measure of success. For a time the countermovement was able to abduct and deprogram converts to new religious movements with relative impunity, and subsequently developed voluntary "exit counseling" procedures have served as functional equivalent in persuading members to renounce their former affiliations (Bromley 1988). Anticult organizations have prompted legislative hearings and investigations at which their grievances could be voiced. They swung public opinion toward some form of legal controls over the organization and operation of unconventional religious movements. And they added "religious cult" and "brainwashing" to the popular vernacular (Bromley and Breschel 1992). Nonetheless, the Anticult Movement has been unable to secure an institutional forum or access to established institutions through which it could invoke social sanctions against its targets. Thus it remains marginal in its stability and influence. The Anticult Movement has confronted resistance from several sources including organizations representing mainstream mental health professionals, which contest the data and methods upon which anti-cult claims rest; the judicial system, which demands empirical verification for legal claims made against the movements; civil libertarian organizations, which fear a limitation of religious liberties will result from distinguishing between acceptable and non-acceptable religious groups; and social scientists engaged in research on the new movements, whose research findings fail to confirm key countermovement allegations. These critics have continued to challenge the assumption of recruitment through brainwashing upon which the concept of "cult," and ultimately the entire anticult agenda, is based. Consider the following: *** Critics point out that it is hard to build a compelling case for subversive mind control on the basis of Korean POW data since only 25 of the approximately 3,500 servicemen held by the communists actually refused repatriation, despite being under the total control of their captors for months or even years. *** There is no plausible explanation for how such a diverse array of groups from different parts of the world and with no connection to one another -- the Hare Krishnas from India, the Unificationists from Korea, The Family in the United States -- all discovered and implemented this psycho-technology at precisely the same moment. *** For a process as potent as brainwashing is purported to be, the results are abysmal. The public recruitment campaigns by these groups produce a conversion success rate that is extremely low, probably considerably lower than conventional churches that proselytize, such as the Mormons and Jehovah's Witnesses. Further, these groups seem equally unsuccessful in retaining converts; in fact, many groups suffer defection rates of fifty to one hundred percent per year (Barker 1984). *** Not only do these movements fail to recruit or retain members successfully, numerous accounts indicate that ongoing members are hardly passive and compliant. In fact, many of these groups manifest a pervasive pattern of factionalism, schism, and conflict. *** Virtually every account of the groups that triggered the cult controversy indicates that they grew very rapidly through the 1970s by recruiting young adults but then began to decline just as rapidly, despite intensive recruitment campaigns, once the counter-culture period of the 1960s ran its course. If coercive mind control is the secret to their success, on the basis on trial and error alone these groups should become more rather than less proficient with practice. The Satanic Cult Episode During the 1980s subversion fears centered on a putative underground cult of practicing satanists organized into a vast international, secret network of tightly organized, hierarchically structured "satanic cults." There is an erie parallel between depictions of religious cults and satanic cults in that the central characteristic of the latter cults too is their knowledge and application of a sophisticated combination of drugging, terrorism, and brainwashing techniques as a means of enslaving the young children whom they target. According to their opponents, Satanists seek primarily enhancement of personal pleasure and power through exploitation of children. Victims are forced to perform as sexual partners for the pleasure of adult satanists or as actors in pornographic films that finance cult activity, and satanists ritualistically sacrifice children in the belief that victims' life energy can thereby be appropriated. In addition to child sacrifice, satanists are believed to be responsible for coordinating a variety of other sinister activities, including worship of Satan, luring youth into satanic cults through dissemination of occult material in fantasy games and subliminal messages implanted in heavy metal rock music, precipitating criminal homicides, and carrying out widespread desecration of graves and mutilation of animals. Antis claim that satanic cults also seek political power and religious status in order to shield their organizations and activity from legal prosecution. They have already infiltrated some institutions, most notably preschools and daycare centers, that provide them with unrestricted access to children. The startling rise in the number of individuals claiming to be "ritual abuse survivors" is presented as dramatic evidence of the rapidly gr owing power and danger posed by satanic cults. The Antisatanism Movement is made up of several loosely connected strands; the focus of attention here is that component of the movement comprised of families with young children whose parents came to believe they were being victimized by organized groups of satanists located in various types of childcare facilities. The historical moment when the Antisatanism Movement emerged was one during which American families experienced an acute sense of loss of control over the welfare of their own children. Among the perceived sources of corrupting or exploitive influence were strangers (abduction, rape, murder), media (violence, sexuality, and antisocial messages in music, television and film), and peer groups (promotion of sexual activity and drug use). The most i mmediate source of tension that led to the rise of satanism fears was competing demands of family and economy, which translated directly into a loss of family control over early childhood socialization (Bromley 1991). Briefly, recent decades have witnessed a decline in income and increasing debt, longer workweeks and less leisure time, and dramatically escalating costs for housing and education. One of the most important outcomes in the middle class has been a sharp increase in the number of women entering the labor force, particularly mothers with young children. As a result, these families have been forced to rely on expensive, unregulated daycare facilities. Given the meteoric rise in sexual abuse allegations and the conviction among certain elements of the mental health professions that many childhood and adult emotional problems are attributable to early childhood abuse, it is not surprising that the emotional tumult surrounding the transfer of childcare to strangers was accompanied by suspicion and reservation. The demonization of daycare is grounded in a fear is that children might be treated as human commodities by daycare centers organized as businesses rather than as sacred trusts by daycare centers organized as surrogate families. What energized the Antisatanism Movement was a coalition between families and a network of entrepreneurial therapists who developed a novel mental health practice, "recovered memory therapy." As Davis (1996:17) summarizes the assumptions underlying this therapy: "The experience of abuse is overwhelming, and so in order to survive, victims must build an internal defense structure to protect themselves. In some cases, victims block all memory of the abuse out of consciousness." It becomes the objective of this form of therapy to recover the deeply buried memories of abuse and to guide the client to linking present emotional distress with prior abuse. In the case of the Antisatanism Movement, during the therapy process, therapists offer satanic ritual abuse as the central theme of the therapy narrative. The process of validating that narrative involves a variety of recovery techniques, which often involve altered states of consciousness, and a support network comprised of therapist, family, and other ritual abuse survivors. The recovered memories of ritual abuse are then proffered as the primary evidence of the existence and operation of the satanic cult network. Like the Anticult Movement, the Antisatanism Movement has had considerable social impact. During local rumor-panics large numbers of families have withdrawn their children from school; for a time law enforcement officials conducted extensive and costly investigations in an effort to locate satanic ritual sites and the remains of ritual sacrifice victims; there has been a plethora of daycare center investigations across the nation based on the fear that these facilities had been infiltrated by satanists; a number of states have created task forces to investigate the possibility of satanic cult activity within their borders; a few states have revised criminal statutes to incorporate penalties for ritualistic crimes; in some criminal trials defendants have been sentenced to extraordinarily long prison terms, usually on the testimony of adult "ritual abuse survivors" or of very young children; and media representatives have given extensive coverage to extreme and bizarre stories of ritual abuse, which has convinced a substantial proportion of the population of the existence of a menacing satanic cult network. As in the case of the religious cult subversion episode, resistance rather soon began to mount from a variety of social locations: family members accused of participating in satanic groups banded together to combat allegations made against them; police agencies began resisting what became interminable investigations that yielded no meaningful physical evidence; jurists have expressed reservations about accepting uncorroborated testimony of young children whose accounts appear to have been influenced by examining therapists; mental health professional associations have resisted theories of recovered memory that would open the door to countless claims and that are impossible to verify (Davis 1996); and legislative bodies have demurred from initiating legislation targeting groups and defining offense categories for which confirming evidence is meager at best. In this instance, it is the very existence of the putative satanic cult network and its ritual sacrifice victims that has been challenged. Critics have noted that research on satanic churches yields no evidence that sexual abuse, child molestation and human sacrifice are elements of their theologies or rituals (Bromley and Ainsley 1995); research on subliminal messages finds neither evidence of satanic messages in recorded music nor significant influence on behavior from subliminal messages generally (Thorne and Himelstein 1984; Vokey and Read 1985); rumor-panics over impending abduction of children by satanists across the country have yielded no actual cases but rather are interpreted as instances of collective behavior deriving from longstanding urban legends with a child endangerment motif (Brunvand 1981; Victor 1990); virtually every investigation of animal mutilation cases has concluded that unexplained large-animal deaths are the product of roadkills, hunting, trapping, disease, or poisoning (Cade 1977; Stewart 1977); and in the several dozen homicide cases attributed to satanism investigators have concluded that perpetrators have confessed to satanic involvement in the hope of diminishing legal responsibility for their acts or to seek publicity by adding a satanic gloss to their crimes. Critics have challenged not only countermovement interpretations of the various events and activities that would attribute them to a satanic conspiracy but also evidence put forth to demonstrate the existence of a satanic cult network. *** No organizational records of any kind (e.g., correspondence, membership lists, phone logs, travel records, bank accounts, meeting places, ritual implements, pornographic films) have ever been recovered from a network that must be large, complex, international in scope and must have engaged in nefarious activities for an extended period of time. Nor is there any evidence of a theology or set or rituals that forms the basis for the current practice of satanism or of any historical tradition from which satanic beliefs and practices might have been drawn. *** Claims that lack of hard evidence proving the existence of the satanic cult network is due to its phenomenonally efficient, infallible organization are belied by the parade of ritual abuse survivors who freely recount their stories to the media. *** The extensiveness of satanic cult network and the estimated number of satanic cult victims is so large as to preclude any possibility that they could be concealed. Indeed, even by conservative countermovement estimates ritual sacrifice victims would equal the total number of war-related deaths from World War II, Korea, and Vietnam combined. Yet despite intensive investigation, there has not been a single discovery of a victim whose death can be linked to a satanic ritual (Lanning 1989). *** Finally, while there is virtually no evidence of either the existence of an international satanic cult network or ritual sacrifice victims, there are numerous instances of refutation of satanic cult claims. For example, there have been a number of instances in which "ritual abuse survivors" have specified the location of ritual sacrifices, but official investigations have not uncovered any evidence (Lyons 1988:143-145); important autobiographical details of survivors lives have been disconfirmed (Passantino et al. 1989; American Library Association 1990); and there is convincing evidence that therapists rather than clients introduce satanism into the jointly constructed therapeutic narratives (Mulhern 1991). Anticultism and Antisatanism: Points of Continuity The preceding synopses of two contemporary subversion episodes rehearses the precipitating tensions and countermovement responses for two cases in which groups in some social locations clearly have understood themselves to be locked in an epic struggle with conspiratorial forces of evil. There are some obvious similarities between the two. Both involve fears of child endangerment. In both, alliances between family members and individuals claiming mental health professional status are key. Both see the undermining of individual autonomy as the main threat. The two countermovements are also alike in that neither has achieved an institutional base or an institutional alliance that confers legitimacy and authorization to invoke social control. Yet both countermovements have achieved influence. For a time at least, public opinion was swayed, public officials were engaged, victimization was validated, and subversives were identified and prosecuted. In each case there was, then, a shared sense that organized subversive groups might well be afoot and endangering the social order before resistance to the subversive conspiracy proposal carried the day. One significant question these two episodes raise, therefore, is how such an intense sense of evil is created. ENCOUNTERING SUBVERSION In the normal course of events humans culturally narrate their own action and become actors in their own narratives. In a subversion episode the socioculturally constructed order is experienced as disintegrating. The resulting sense of disorder is constructed as a dramatic encounter between the forces of good and subversive evil. The question posed here is how that sense of dramatic confrontation is so powerfully created in countersubversion narratives. The proposed answer is that the stage upon which human action takes place and the cast of actors scripted into the action both expand. At least in the most extreme subversion episodes, those caught up in the drama perceive that what they believed to be a single world is actually two worlds. The "Other" is a subversive order that has suddenly intersected their own world, and it is the clash of these two mutually opposed orders that organizes and energizes the drama. I shall argue that six elements are integral to constructing subversive evil in countersubversion n arratives. The first four elements of the countersubversion narrative construct the staging and plot of the drama. They describe the history, location, power and purpose of subversives. First, subversive evil has a transcendent temporality; that is, it possesses its own historical existence and course, about which little is known, and therefore it appears and recurs unpredictably in times and places of its own choosing. The apparent stability and order of the everyday world can therefore be unexpectedly disrupted by subversive forces, and the present is transformed into a moment of high drama. Second, subversive evil is given transcendent spatiality; that is, it is located in a separate domain. Subversives are defined as aliens who exist outside of conventional society in concealed, secret locations where their sinister activity is shielded from public view. They infiltrate conventional society from these remote sites. This separation of the conventional and subversive worlds makes for dramatic encounters across the boundary points and within the conventional domain as clusters of subversives are discovered. Third, subversive evil involves transcendent power; that is, exotic, potent power capable of corrupting and undermining individuals' normal, natural essence. A highpoint of the drama occurs when subversives unleash their overwhelming power on unwitting victims, rendering them thralls to subversive purpose. Fourth, subversive organization typically is symbolized as the inversion of legitimate organization; it is described as complex, conspiratorial, and dedicated to nefarious purpose. These categorical distinctions become the basis for the dramatic battle between the forces of good and evil. Fifth, the countersubversion narrative provides an identification of the key actors in the drama, in this case the most important are innocent victims, evil perpetrators, and heroic defenders. It is the through these three roles that the dramatic encounters are enacted. Finally, the narrative is directed toward audience mobilization, that is, third parties who may be drawn into the drama as allies of countermovement activists. Audience mobilization is effected through heightening apprehension about subversives as a large, rapidly growing force that is on the verge of taking over one or more sectors of the social order, is extremely dangerous, and is impervious to normal social control mechanisms. Transcendent Temporality: Historical Roots of Contemporary Evil Historical continuity is created primarily through linking cultic brainwashing to communist thought reform programs in China and the former Soviet Union during the Korean War era. The parent of a young woman who joined the Unification Church draws precisely that connection in explaining her daughter's conversion: "We think the brainwashing is very similar to what happened to our prisoners of war in Korea. It's a system of mind control the Orientals know very well, but we know very little about" (Shupe and Bromley, 1981a:179). Two behavioral scientists connected with the Anticult Movement identify "first and second generations of interest." The latter is a more potent attack on individuals as it targets the core as opposed to the periphery of the self. They aver that first generation programs simply attack "one's political and social views" while second generation programs of the type employed by religious cults "appear to directly attack the core sense of being -- the central self-image, the very sense of realness and existence of the self" (Ofshe and Singer 1986:18). Similarly, contemporary Satanism is represented as the most recent in a long series of incursions by satanic forces that extend over countless human generations and even societal histories. These eruptions of Satanism appear in diverse forms in different historical eras, and sometimes their true source is not correctly identified by contemporaries of the period. In a close parallel to the linking of religious cult practices to communist brainwashing, contemporary satanists' brainwashing and drugging of victims are traced in some accounts to medical experiments conducted by Nazi physicians. The doctors who developed these techniques (and a mysterious, infamous Dr. Green, in particular) are alleged to be satanists who brought their destructive knowledge with them when they fled Germany and settled in the United States. Again, the current outbreak is particularly pernicious. One "cult crime specialist" places contemporary satanism in historical context while distinguishing the unique and virulent current outbreak in daycare centers (Geraldo, "Satanic Cults and Children," 19 November 1987): Well, cults have always existed throughout history, but it's only been recently that they've really become very active in this country. 1982 is a period or cycle for them that's known - every 28 years is the "feast of the beast" and it last occurred in 1982. And it gives them a whole new game plan on what they're doing. Well, part of what their game plan was to infiltrate preschool centers and such and to bring others into their service. Transcendent Spatiality: The Cultic Realm Anti-cult accounts often stress the remote, secretive, impenetrable sites that cults occupy. Ted Patrick, a founder of the anti-cult movement and the originator of deprogramming, provides an account of a rural Children of God commune to which he gained entrance (Patrick with Dulack 1976:62). The colony was way up in the mountains, some twenty-four miles back on a dirt road five miles off the main highway. There was nothing else on the road except the colony, which consisted of three buildings -- old farm buildings -- surrounded by a seven-foot-high fence with a locked gate.... The grounds were patrolled by three vicious German shepherds. And one of the buildings was topped by a watchtower so that no one could come up that road without being detected at least five minutes before he reached the gate. He depicts himself as on the verge of becoming a virtual prisoner, using the term "escape" in reference to making plans to leave the commune. Renderings of satanic cults emphasize their underground, secret, hidden, nature in locations such as cemeteries, isolated wooded sites, or even the criminal "underworld." In a recent California court case, for example, two daughters and the grand-daughter of a 76-year-old woman testified that the woman forced them to engage in a variety of perverted sexual acts, infanticide, and even cannibalism. One of the daughters asserted that the rituals in which she was forced to take part were conducted in secret caves that probably are located in the surrounding San Bernadino mountains ("Forced to Kill Her Baby, Woman Says," Los Angeles Times, 21 March 1991). In Cults That Kill (1988:vii), law enforcement official Larry Kahaner describes how he discovered an entire underworld satanic domain in the course of investigating surface-level manifestations of Satanism. I found a hidden society, much larger and more disquieting than the world of Satanism alone, a place few people know exists....It is the underworld of "occult crime."...The crimes are frightening:... ritual sacrifices at wooded sites where black-robed cultists mutilate animals on alters; other homicides where the corpses are found drained of blood with symbols such as a pentagram or inverted cross carved into their chests;...Satanic rituals and human sacrifices involving children -- fantastic stories told by hundreds of children in scores of preschools throughout the United States, all of them relating similar horrors. Transcendent Power: Imposition of Subversive Control At the height of the religious cult subversion episode, brainwashing was regarded as so highly coercive that even a perfunctory encounter with cultists might result in loss of free will. A variety of apostates from new religious movements testify to being subjected to such techniques. By one such account (Edwards 1979:60): "She took my hand and looked me straight in the eyes. As her wide eyes gazed into mine, I felt myself rapidly losing control, being drawn to her by a strange and frightening force. I had never felt such mysterious power radiate from a human being before." In a more sophisticated formulation, Flo Conway and Jim Siegelman (1979:134-135) argue that cultic mind control results in "snapping," a novel phenomenon that goes beyond intense physical experiences and psychological stresses by incorporating what they call a "different kind of information." Individuals subjected to this process may surrender and relinquish control over their own wills. "And more than anything else it is this act of capitulation that sets off the explosion we call snapping....In that moment, something quite remarkable may happen. With that flick of a switch, that change of heart and mind, an individual's personality may come apart." The result, anticult proponents contend, is that cult members remain in a dissociated state, which results in mental disorder and prevents individuals from being able to express their individual autonomy. As one Anticult Movement affiliated therapist commented after evaluating a young woman who joined the Hare Krishna, "It's my opinion that she was not at that point freely using her own will and volition, but being influenced and manipulated and made to comply with the wishes of the various Krishna organization representatives" (Bromley 1989:276). Parents of members of religious cults report that they begin to suspect cultic brainwashing when they observe such changes in personality. In one such account, for example, "His parents noticed with alarm that he was becoming pale, withdrawn, nervous and acting almost as if he were in a trance....He was becoming a walking zombie and nothing at all like the son we had known" (Shupe and Bromley, 1981c:256). According to the satanic cult countersubversion ideology, brainwashing is practiced upon very young children, who are extremely vulnerable and who may be under the control of satanists for years at a time. This combination of high vulnerability and prolonged exposure creates an enormous capacity for control. "The process of ritual abuse takes place over an extended period of time, often for years. The process includes a variety of exercises and ceremonies, each with an intended purpose, and which collectively attack all levels of the child's normal orientation" (Massachusetts State Police, Roll Call Newsletter, January, 1989, pp. 3-4). Therapists who treat individuals designated as "ritual abuse survivors" have attempted to discover the nature of the brainwashing techniques employed by satanists based on the material elicited from clients during the therapy process. One therapist (Snowden, n.d.), who has compiled a list of these techniques, asserts that satanists induce dissociation to fragment the personality, shatter emotional spontaneity, disrupt the developmental process, and destroy all memory of the brainwashing process. She describes the brainwashing process, which is often combined with drugging, as "...sophisticated hypnosis which involves the associative pairing of induced pain/terror & the cult message & the trigger cue(s)...planted in the unconscious....They are later utilized by the cult to control the survivor without his or her conscious awareness." One individual claiming to be a survivor describes her experiences in terms that closely parallel religious cult brainwashing claims (Smith and Pazder, 1980:102): I had no idea how long the struggle went on. In Victor's windowless basement, time had no meaning. It could have been a day, a week, a month...I just couldn't tell. I do know that as each hour passed, each minute became more agonizing. I was forced to endure sleep and food deprivation. Certainly I was familiar with torture, but not this type. There were no rituals....This was the kind of breaking process I had heard that prisoners of war went through in concentration camps. She remembers that her capacity to resist was finally broken when she was confined in a barrel with the lid closed and the parts of a sacrificed baby were dropped on top of her. She recalls, "It was over. I was broken. Brainwashed" (Smith and Pazder 1980:104). --[cont]-- Aloha, He'Ping, Om, Shalom, Salaam. Em Hotep, Peace Be, Omnia Bona Bonis, All My Relations. Adieu, Adios, Aloha. Amen. Roads End Kris DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
