If there were a way to isolate it to one of the dates, yes, that would work. However that inserts too much assumption..
From: owner-deadli...@nemesis.cs.berkeley.edu [mailto:owner-deadli...@nemesis.cs.berkeley.edu] On Behalf Of Charlie Miller Sent: Friday, February 25, 2011 3:12 PM To: kevin; 'Caleb Kennedy'; 'deadli...@gdead.berkeley.edu' Subject: Re: 10/5/70 Winterland Process of elimination. It's not 10/4 and not 12/23. From: kevin <mailto:ke...@shallwego.net> Sent: Friday, February 25, 2011 4:23 PM To: 'Charlie Miller' <mailto:charliemille...@earthlink.net> ; 'Caleb Kennedy' <mailto:thehor...@earthlink.net> ; 'deadli...@gdead.berkeley.edu' Subject: RE: 10/5/70 Winterland There is no posted evidence that it belongs to 10/5. Please provide From: Charlie Miller [mailto:charliemille...@earthlink.net] Sent: Friday, February 25, 2011 12:34 PM To: Caleb Kennedy; kevin; deadli...@gdead.berkeley.edu Subject: Re: 10/5/70 Winterland The reels I have from 12/23/70 have a different me and my uncle than the one that circulates. the one tht circs is from 10/5/70. From: Caleb Kennedy <mailto:thehor...@earthlink.net> Sent: Friday, February 25, 2011 6:59 AM To: kevin <mailto:ke...@shallwego.net> ; deadli...@gdead.berkeley.edu Subject: RE: 10/5/70 Winterland That looks like the gist of it. Charlie Miller has announced that he has the master of 12/23/70 and will presumably be issuing it; so we'll soon see whether the Hard to Handle, Candyman, and MAMU are from 12/23 or not... -----Original Message----- >From: kevin <ke...@shallwego.net> >Sent: Feb 24, 2011 5:03 PM >To: 'Caleb Kennedy' <thehor...@earthlink.net>, >deadlists@nemesis.CS.Berkeley.EDU >Subject: RE: 10/5/70 Winterland > >To simplify that drawn out blog entry, this is what I've deciphered: > >12/17/70 list >Hard To Handle - No evidence where it really belongs. Based on the confusion >could just as well be part of the real 12/23 as that list is incomplete >Candyman - ditto >Me And My Uncle - ditto >Cold Rain And Snow - Side by side listening proves this is from 10/4 >Dancing In The Street - - Side by side listening proves this is from 10/5 > >12/23/70 list >Cold Rain And Snow (on both 12/23 and 12/17) - Side by side listening proves >this is from 10/4 >Dancing In The Street (on both 12/23 and 12/17) - Side by side listening >proves this is from 10/5 >Uncle John's Band - - Side by side listening proves this is from 10/4 > >I think this covers the gist of it. Please confirm. > >Kevin
