[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: >Clause A.2: > >| 2. The person making the modifications must be identified. > >This fails to allow anonymous modifications and thus fails the >Dissident test, it's a restriction on modifications (I have to >give up something, namely my anonymity, in order to get permission >to modify), see DFSG#3. The dissident test is not part of the DFSG, nothing in DFSG #3 says that you must be guaranteed anonymity and anyway it's a generic request for "identification", which could as well be a pseudonym.
>| 2. The author be notified by email of the modification in advance of >| redistribution, if an email address is provided in the document. > >_If_ the document includes "an email address", this fails to the >Desert Island test, discriminates against people that do not have Which is not part of the DFSG either, so it's not much relevant when evaluating the freeness of a license. >Internet access (or anyway the possibility to send e-mail messages): >fails DFSG#5. I do not believe that this can be considered "discrimination" relevant for DFSG #5. -- ciao, Marco -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with a subject of "unsubscribe". Trouble? Contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
