John Robinson said: >another example: DPL election, two candidates, R=45 > >450x DAB > 45x ADB > >Condorcet: D wins >Proposed: A wins >Amended: D wins
You appear to be making the same mistake as Manoj did, which I noted in a message to debian-devel. Under the proposed system (Manoj's), B is dropped. This leaves: 450x DA 45x AD The default option beats A and wins. An option which is *beaten* by the default option *cannot* win unless both it and the Default Option are in the Smith set. Construct your examples better. Both of you! --Nathanael
