On 9/23/07, Sean Kelley <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> I think GIT is not a very user friendly SCM for those coming from
> other version control systems.  It is far too rough around the edges.
> Will it get better?  I am sure over time it will.  But I certainly
> wouldn't impose it on the multitude of Gnome developers who have
> varying degress of SCM experience from the git go. :-)


Garmin's massive one-way pulling of source from a ton of projects probably
dosen't make for a good test case. There's a number of things about your
situatation that are unique and won't apply to those of us maintaining
modules.

As I understand it from those I know on the inside, you're more-or-less
forking what you deem to be "stable" snapshots of OSS libraries and
maintaining your own company-local repositories that only Garmin developers
use. The only merging your doing is taking patches from upstream and
backporting them to the libraries you guys have decided to use for your hand
helds...  please correct me if I'm miss-informed.

I'm a little skeptical that your experience will apply to anyone else
(except perhaps Nokia and Motorola) based on what I know...
_______________________________________________
desktop-devel-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/desktop-devel-list

Reply via email to