On Thu, Jul 10, 2008 at 2:46 PM, Brian Hudson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > "Has anyone tried this to see if the bugs have been fixed that affect > our psf files?" > > I am using Ganymede and have used several of the .psf files without issue.
The .psf files are Subclipse-specific, so presumably you are using Subclipse. What version? What special settings, if any, to work around the problem? I haven't seen any Subclipse releases since Collabnet updated the Eclipse bug report saying that it would be in the next version they made available. > "Now that Subversive has been chosen over Subclipse for integration into > Eclipse, the Collabnet folks may be thinking of dropping Subclipse or > reducing its priority relative to other projects, so we should probably be > considering switching." > > I don't think Suclipse will be going away anytime soon, and in my opinion > its the better plug-in anyways. > > Mark Phippard (a Subclipse/CollabNet dev) had this to say on another blog I > read: > > "...Eclipse did not pick one plug-in over the other. Eclipse does not pick > anything. Projects make proposals to become an Eclipse.org project and as > long as they follow the guidelines they are generally approved. We made the > conscious decision to not make the Subclipse project part of Eclipse.org. It's true that Subversive wasn't picked over Subclipse, because Collabnet withdrew the Subclipse proposal, but whether it's because of the IP considerations mentioned in the blog you quote (http://www.stevestreeting.com/2008/02/20/fickle-creatures-are-we/), or because they knew they'd lose, or because of internal Collabnet commercial considerations, is impossible to know. The rest that follows that first sentence though is all just spin. Subversive *is* an official Eclipse project. It *did* get picked/approved. It is *not* an automatic process as Mark tries to imply. What impact this will have long term remains to be seen, but I've got to believe that being the official SVN plugin is going to give Subversive an advantage over time. Having said all that, I'd really, REALLY like Subclipse to fix the bug, so if there's a release that's got the bug fix in it, I'd love to hear about it. Tom --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
