Michael>I still think
Michael>this should be communicated to the original contributor along with
a link
Michael>to the fix. This at least gives the person an opportunity to learn.

I have linked the original PR and the fix, and it did help Zoltan to note
an alternative implementation.

Julian>Your behavior was extremely rude.

Do you mean just CALCITE-2327?
Do you mean other cases?

Julian>It does seem that you were technically correct in this case. But we
require civility in this community.

Does that imply the behavior was not civil?

The bug is trivial, and I really see no reasons to spend time on discussing
the bits.

Remember: CALCITE-2327/PR707 was inactive since July. The fix takes just
10-20minutes.
What sense does it make to ping the issue?
I would rather commit the fix than spend days on discussion. No-one would
learn from that discussion.

As you remember, bike-shedding causes
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CALCITE-2438

Vladimir

Reply via email to