There is a discussion in the Incubator list [1] that proposes a more
structured format for the line that people write in their email
message when they vote.

The problem is that some people use multiple names, email accounts,
github accounts, and that tallying votes requires some effort.

The proposed solution is that people would use a structured line when
they vote, consisting of their vote (-1, 0, +1), their ASF id if they
have one, and their role (committer, PMC member, community member).
For example, my vote would be

  +1 jhyde (PMC)

In my opinion, Calcite should adopt this. The email starting a vote
would recommend that people use that format. Votes would still be
counted if people use a different format.

What do you think?

Julian

[1] https://lists.apache.org/thread/xkfrnt8f733hhokmh0lvyhsn50x4qfw0

Reply via email to