On Wed, May 6, 2015 at 5:07 AM, <[email protected]> wrote: > I would suggest having most work in the github world, and a published method > for new contributors to do a normal github fork and pull approach. > Contributors can then use a process to migrate that to apache git once it is > approved for merge. That allows use of the github infra for review and a > public face where, at the moment, people would expect it to be.
I would strongly advise against that. All of the discussion should happen on the ASF mailing lists or other infrastructure-supported tools. We should not be having discussions solely within the GitHub infrastructure. One of the key lockins is that GitHub does not support exporting those comments on a PR - so, when GitHub disappears (which it will eventually), all of that information will be lost. If Geode simply wanted to be a GitHub project, it didn't need to come to Apache. My $.02. -- justin
