Interesting, I haven't seen any cases where OfflineMetaRepair was really required, among our customer base (running cdh6.1.x/hbase2.1.1, cdh6.2/hbase2.1.2). Majority of RITs issue I had came with on hbase 2.x were related to APs/SCPs failures, most of which could be sorted with hbck2 commands available by then (in some cases, required some CLI scripting to build up a "bulk" assign command).
Em qua, 29 de mai de 2019 às 00:55, Toshihiro Suzuki <brfrn...@apache.org> escreveu: > Hi Josh, > > Thank you for the explanation. I agree with the direction for HBCK2. > > The problem I wanted to tell you in the Jira is that until we implement the > features > you mentioned, we don't have any direct way how to fix holes and overlaps. > The holes and overlaps can be created by bugs or operation errors, so I > think we > should be able to fix these issues. > > I thought OfflineMetaRepair could be a workaround for the issues until we > implement > the features of HBCK2. > > Regards, > Toshi > > > On Tue, May 28, 2019 at 9:12 AM Josh Elser <els...@apache.org> wrote: > > > Context: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/HBASE-21665 > > > > I left a comment on the above issue about what I thought good things to > > build into HBCK2 would be -- a focus on specific "primitive" operations > > that an admin/operator could use to help repair an otherwise broken > > HBase installation. Some examples I had in my head were: > > > > * Create an empty region (to plug a hole) > > * Report holes in a region chain > > > > In my head, the difference for HBCK2 was that we want to give folks the > > tools to fix their cluster, but we did not want to own the "just fix > > everything" kind of tool that HBCK1 had become. That problem with HBCK1 > > was that it was often difficult/problematic for us to know how to > > correctly fix a problem (the same problem could be corrected in > > different ways). > > > > Andrew had some confusion about this, so I'm not sure if I'm off-base or > > if we're all in agreement on direction and we just need to do a better > > job documenting things. Thanks for keeping me honest either way :) > > > > And just in case it doesn't go without saying, HBCK2 would be something > > that helps fix a system, while we want to always understand the root > > cause of how/why we got into a situation where we needed HBCK2 and also > > address that. > > > > - Josh > > >
