That'd be a helpful step. I think it'd be even better if there was a way to generate somewhat customized versions of solr from the artifacts that are published already. Publishing the whole zip would be a start, downstream builds could add logic to resolve it, explode, tweak, and re-publish. The maintain the strict separation from the war, it might be helpful to have a lib or "plugin-ins" folder in the zip that is by default loaded to the classpath as an extension point for users who are re-building the package?
-Tim From: email@example.com At: 10/18/16 09:52:42 To: firstname.lastname@example.org Subject: Re: Building a Solr cluster with Maven My team has modified the ant scripts to publish all the jars/poms and the zip to our local artifactory when we run our build. We have another project which pulls down all of these dependencies including the zip to build our actual solr deploy and a maven assembly which unpacks the zip file and extracts all of the webapp for our real distribution. I haven't upstreamed the changes for the ant tasks thinking there wouldn't be too much interest in that, but I could put together a patch if there is. The changes do the following: - Packages the zip along with the parent pom if a flag is set - Allows changing group which the poms are published to. For example instead of org.apache you can push it as com.xxx to avoid shadowing conflicts in your local repository. On Tue, Oct 18, 2016 at 8:42 AM David Smiley <david.w.smi...@gmail.com> wrote: Thanks for bringing this up, Greg. I too have felt the pain of this in the move away from a WAR file in a project or two. In one of the projects that comes to mind, we built scripts that re-constituted a Solr distribution from artifacts in Maven. For anything that wasn't in Maven (e.g. the admin UI pages, Jetty configs), we checked it into source control. In hind sight... the simplicity of what you list as (1) -- check the distro zip into a Maven repo local to the organization sounds better... but I may be forgetting requirements that led us not to do this. I look forward to that zip shrinking once the docs are gone. Another option, depending on one's needs, is to pursue Docker, which I've lately become a huge fan of. I think Docker is particularly great for integration tests. Does the scenario you wish to use the assets for relate to testing or some other use-case? ~ David On Mon, Oct 17, 2016 at 7:58 PM Greg Pendlebury <greg.pendleb...@gmail.com> wrote: Are there any developers with a current working maven build for a downstream Solr installation? ie. Not a build for Solr itself, but a build that brings in the core Solr server plus local plugins, third party plugins etc? I am in the process of updating one of our old builds (it builds both the application and various shard instances) and have hit a stumbling block in sourcing the dashboard static assets (everything under /webapp/web in Solr's source). Prior to the move away from being a webapp I could get them by exploding the war from Maven Central. In our very first foray into 5.x we had a local custom build to patch SOLR-2649. We avoided solving this problem then by pushing the webapp into our local Nexus as part of that build... but that wasn't a very good long term choice. So now I'm trying to work out the best long term approach to take here. Ideas so far: 1)Manually download the required zip and add it into our Nexus repository as a 3rd party artifact. Maven can source and extract anything it needs from here. This is where I'm currently leaning for simplicity, but the manual step required is annoying. It does have the advantage of causing a build failure straight away when a version upgrade occurs, prompting the developer to look into why. 2)Move a copy of the static assets for the dashboard into our project and deploy them ourselves. This has the advantage of aligning our approach with the resources we already maintain in the project (like core.properties, schema.xml, solrconfig.xml, logging etc.). But I am worried that it is really fragile and developers will miss it during a version upgrade, resulting in the dashboard creeping out-of-date and (worse) introducing subtle bugs because of a version mismatch between the UI and the underlying server code. 3)I'd like to think a long term approach would be for the core Solr build to ship a JAR (or any other assembly) to Maven Central like 'solr-dashboard'... but I'm not sure how that aligns with the move away from Solr being considered a webapp. It seems a shame that all of the Java code ends up in Maven central, but the web layer dead-ends in the ant build. I might be missing something really obvious and there is already a way to do this. Is there some other distribution of the dashboard statics? Other than the downloadable zip that is. Ta, Greg -- Lucene/Solr Search Committer, Consultant, Developer, Author, Speaker LinkedIn: http://linkedin.com/in/davidwsmiley | Book: http://www.solrenterprisesearchserver.com