> > 1.) The tarballs include transitive dependencies (like commons-lang). > > We don't want to ship those with our nightly or official releases > > Why not, I build with the transitive dependencies would be easy to use > for the user. I think we should ship with the dependencies.
I disagree. We don't want to distribute the jakarta-commons jars, etc. I agree that its ok for the examples (they go in the WAR) b/c it makes testing the examples easier. Can the transitive dependency part be turned off? Is that an option with assembly? If so, please turn it off. That's the way our nightly builds (and releases) have been up until now. > > > > 2.) Maven assembly doesn't really allow you to easily create both > > source and bin tarballs. > What should contain the source tarball? Take a look at the last (1.1.1) release. There is a source tarball there. Sean
