Hi Sebastien, This is the last time that I will eat the bait!
I agree that all commits should have some proper git commit message and that is something that normally I always ask for! And as others already commented this is part of a bigger PR and this specific commit is very intuitive. So, instead of contributing to this project you are always saying bad things about it. If you developed your own RTOS, good for you, I wish you good luck with it. So, don't waste your time here, focus on your RTOS and let those who really care about this project do their work. Please do a favor to our small community: move on! BR, Alan On Tue, Jan 28, 2025 at 7:24 AM Sebastien Lorquet <sebast...@lorquet.fr> wrote: > my trust in nuttx is now hard to maintain. > > Every day a DELUGE of commits (from xiaomi, this is a fact) is added to > the repository. > > I am struggling to understand what happens in this project. > > so many fixes are pushed, how is that even possible? this is a quicksand > project! > > > Also, how are such commits (not from xiaomi!) allowed? No description > except "uf2" ? Where is the adult in charge? > > > https://github.com/apache/nuttx/commit/dac3f315a11cead82a5f630d4ae1c3eb45a80377 > > > I am announcing that after that many years my company has started to > develop a minimal rtos to replace our usage of nuttx, because it is just > not stable enough to be usable for stable long term projects. > > There are too many changes, we are loosing money every time we need an > update. there is no way to maintain the use of a nuttx custom board and > project over several years. > > Having control of our code will be a better investment. That will > obviously be closed source. Which is, after all, a better way of control > on our products. > > > No amount of my involvement in the github triage is going to help, the > case is desperate. I just have no time, no energy, no motivation, no > spoons left to deal with this. it's a deluge of commits, let it be, but > without me. > > the warning from the apache foundation that you use too many ci credits > should have been a warning to slow down and reflect on the project > direction. nothing has happened except making it even faster. > > I will also discourage people to use this project, I cannot in good > conscience recommend it to anyone, it would be a trap. > > goodbye. > > > Sebastien > >
