Yes I agree, else you could reserve something which will never be created So we stick here rather than commenting in Jira?
Jacques From: "Scott Gray" <[email protected]> > Carsten is referring to this: >> On confirmation of the production run (action = Confirm), the AtP of the >> product to be produced must increase > > ATP for the products to be produced shouldn't increase until they are > actually available. > > Regards > Scott > > On 21/08/2013, at 1:14 AM, Pierre Smits wrote: > >> Hi Carsten, >> >> Thanks for your feedback. >> >> However, this is much like the handling of sales orders on products. When >> registering an order the inventory of the product is not adjusted, but only >> the AtP of the good. Likewise, the confirmation of a production run does >> not trigger the inventory mutation. That only happens when goods are >> released to the production run (action 'Issue Components'). >> >> But it should adjust the AtP. So that Requirements (for PO) and/or PO can >> be created earlier than when QoH reaches 0. Because in current situation >> both AtP and QoH are adjusted at the same moment (when components are >> issued and production output is declared). >> >> But also, when the AtP of the end product (the good to be produced)is >> adjusted at the moment of confirmation of the production run, no unwanted >> (incorrect) production runs will be generated due to MRP processes. >> >> I also want to remind you that currently running production runs can not be >> terminated with the 'Cancel'-action. >> >> Regards, >> >> Pierre Smits >> >> >> On Tue, Aug 20, 2013 at 2:20 PM, <[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> See my previous comments on the mailing list. I disagre with this >>> behaviour. >>> >>> The current behaviour reflects reality much better (I do not say this is >>> ideal). Taking raw materials out and putting inexistent stock in at the >>> confirmation of a production will result in incorrect accounts for both, >>> raws and end products, >>> >>> If we touch this, I suggest we check out inventory when work actually >>> begins (this is NOT when the prodrun is confirmed, but rather when the >>> first actual routing task is started) and allow to return a fraction of >>> checked out inventory when a prod run is cancelled. >>> The end product should only be added to stock/inventory when the prod run >>> is confirmed (allowing for example a QA function to confirm the Prod run >>> and add only the fraction of end products that have passed QA. >>> >>> Both, the check out of raw as well as the confirmation of end products >>> work in OFBiz as described above. Thus this JIra record should focus at the >>> inventory behaviour when production runs are cancelled. >>> >>> Regards >>> >>> >>> Carsten >>> >>> >>> ------Original Message------ >>> From: Pierre Smits (JIRA) >>> To: [email protected] >>> ReplyTo: [email protected] >>> Subject: [jira] [Created] (OFBIZ-5296) AtP of products should be adjusted >>> when production run is confirmed >>> Sent: Aug 20, 2013 14:09 >>> >>> Pierre Smits created OFBIZ-5296: >>> ----------------------------------- >>> >>> Summary: AtP of products should be adjusted when production >>> run is confirmed >>> Key: OFBIZ-5296 >>> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/OFBIZ-5296 >>> Project: OFBiz >>> Issue Type: Improvement >>> Components: manufacturing, product >>> Affects Versions: SVN trunk >>> Reporter: Pierre Smits >>> >>> >>> When a production run is confirmed we know what is intended to go in the >>> production run (the components or ingredients aka the raw materials) and >>> what is intended to go out (the finished product). >>> >>> Unlike with an order, the AtP (Availability to Promise) of the goods >>> involved does not get adjusted. >>> The result is that requirements for PO or even the PO itself get generated >>> to late (at the moment when QoH reaches minimum stock in stead of when AtP >>> reaches minimum stock). >>> >>> Following scenarios need to be resolved: >>> 1. On confirmation of the production run (action = Confirm), the AtP of >>> the product to be produced must increase and the AtP of materials needed >>> must decrease. >>> >>> 2. When production is running and materials have been released to the >>> production run, it is possible to return materials back to inventory. When >>> doing so, the AtP of the materials must be adjusted accordingly with the >>> same date-time and quantity as the returned materials. >>> >>> 3. When a production run has rejected end products the AtP of the end >>> product must be adjusted with the same date-time and quantity as the >>> declaration of the rejected product. >>> >>> -- >>> This message is automatically generated by JIRA. >>> If you think it was sent incorrectly, please contact your JIRA >>> administrators >>> For more information on JIRA, see: http://www.atlassian.com/software/jira >>> >>> Gesendet mit BlackBerry® Webmail von Telekom Deutschland > >
