Hi Lukas,

I think that Modbus+ is a completely different thing. Seems to be related to 
routing of Modbus traffic ... haven't looked too deep at it. 

From the Spec side there are 3 variants:
- Modbus TCP
- Modbus RTU
- Modbus ASCII

In general Modbus RTU and ASCII are sort of the same (Serial) ... the main 
difference is the encoding of the payload and the termination of frames. That's 
why I'll leave the ModbusSerialAdu as topmost packet in both Modbus RTU and 
ASCII, as the difference is handled on the level between the transport and the 
driver. 

Please correct me if I'm wrong,

Chris

-----Original Message-----
From: Lukas Ott <[email protected]> 
Sent: Mittwoch, 9. März 2022 16:48
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Rename "modbus" to "modbus-tcp"?

+1

I would follow the most common naming convention and call the drivers the
following:
- Modbus ASCII
      - Supported Devices: Any Device Supporting Modbus ASII, Any Modbus ASCII 
Comliant PLC, Flow Computers
- Modbus TCP/ IP (What is Modbus TCP/IP ? | Modbus Tcp/ip vs Ethernet ip - The 
Automization <https://theautomization.com/what-is-modbus-tcp-ip/>)
    - Supported Devices: Applicom: Generic Modbus, TSX Premium, TSX Quantum, 
Fluenta FGM, Instromet, Mailbox, Modbus Ethernet, Roxar RFM
- Modbus Plus (Difference between Modbus & Modbus Plus | Instrumentation and 
Control Engineering (automationforum.co) 
<https://automationforum.co/difference-between-modbus-modbus-plus/> )
      - Supported Devices: AT-984 Programmable Controller Board, Hilscher CIF 
Card, Modbus Plus ISA PC Adapter Card, Modbus Plus PCI PC Adapter Card, Modbus 
Plus Type II PCMCIA Card, Modbus Plus Type III PCMCIA Card, Modbus Plus Type 
III PnP PCMCIA Card, SA85 (-002 and -001) PC Interface Cards, SA85-PCI
- Modbus Serial
    - Supported Devices: Daniel S500 Flow Computer, Dynamic Fluid Meter, Elliot 
Flow Computer, Magnetek GPD 515 Drive, Modbus Compatible Devices, Omni Flow 
Computer (Enron Modbus), TSXCUSBMBP USB Adapter
- Modbus RTU Server Serial
    - Any Modbus compatible devices

Modbus ASCII vs Modbus RTU vs Modbus TCP/IP - The Automization 
<https://theautomization.com/modbus-ascii-vs-modbus-rtu-vs-modbus-tcpip/>

To sum up, basically following your suggestion: modbus-tcp, modbus-rtu and 
modbus-ascii sounds like a good approach.

Cheers,
otluk



Am Mi., 9. März 2022 um 15:19 Uhr schrieb Christofer Dutz <
[email protected]>:

> Hi all,
>
> I'm currently working on the modbus RTU stuff ... as in general the 
> protocols are referred to modbus-tcp, modbus-rtu und modbus-ascii, I 
> would like to rename the "modbus" to "modbus-tcp" ... While modbus-tcp 
> will not be many variants, will the modbus-rtu and ascii also be 
> available as "modbus-rtu:tcp" if a tcp tunnel is used.
>
> What do you think?
>
> Chris
>

Reply via email to