Exactly this is why I gave a +1 and confirmed the three suggested naming conventions. Just listed additionally all publicly known Modbus related protocols so that everyone in the community is on the same page :-)
Am Mi., 9. März 2022 um 17:07 Uhr schrieb Christofer Dutz < [email protected]>: > Hi Lukas, > > I think that Modbus+ is a completely different thing. Seems to be related > to routing of Modbus traffic ... haven't looked too deep at it. > > From the Spec side there are 3 variants: > - Modbus TCP > - Modbus RTU > - Modbus ASCII > > In general Modbus RTU and ASCII are sort of the same (Serial) ... the main > difference is the encoding of the payload and the termination of frames. > That's why I'll leave the ModbusSerialAdu as topmost packet in both Modbus > RTU and ASCII, as the difference is handled on the level between the > transport and the driver. > > Please correct me if I'm wrong, > > Chris > > -----Original Message----- > From: Lukas Ott <[email protected]> > Sent: Mittwoch, 9. März 2022 16:48 > To: [email protected] > Subject: Re: [DISCUSS] Rename "modbus" to "modbus-tcp"? > > +1 > > I would follow the most common naming convention and call the drivers the > following: > - Modbus ASCII > - Supported Devices: Any Device Supporting Modbus ASII, Any Modbus > ASCII Comliant PLC, Flow Computers > - Modbus TCP/ IP (What is Modbus TCP/IP ? | Modbus Tcp/ip vs Ethernet ip - > The Automization <https://theautomization.com/what-is-modbus-tcp-ip/>) > - Supported Devices: Applicom: Generic Modbus, TSX Premium, TSX > Quantum, Fluenta FGM, Instromet, Mailbox, Modbus Ethernet, Roxar RFM > - Modbus Plus (Difference between Modbus & Modbus Plus | Instrumentation > and Control Engineering (automationforum.co) < > https://automationforum.co/difference-between-modbus-modbus-plus/> ) > - Supported Devices: AT-984 Programmable Controller Board, Hilscher > CIF Card, Modbus Plus ISA PC Adapter Card, Modbus Plus PCI PC Adapter Card, > Modbus Plus Type II PCMCIA Card, Modbus Plus Type III PCMCIA Card, Modbus > Plus Type III PnP PCMCIA Card, SA85 (-002 and -001) PC Interface Cards, > SA85-PCI > - Modbus Serial > - Supported Devices: Daniel S500 Flow Computer, Dynamic Fluid Meter, > Elliot Flow Computer, Magnetek GPD 515 Drive, Modbus Compatible Devices, > Omni Flow Computer (Enron Modbus), TSXCUSBMBP USB Adapter > - Modbus RTU Server Serial > - Any Modbus compatible devices > > Modbus ASCII vs Modbus RTU vs Modbus TCP/IP - The Automization < > https://theautomization.com/modbus-ascii-vs-modbus-rtu-vs-modbus-tcpip/> > > To sum up, basically following your suggestion: modbus-tcp, modbus-rtu and > modbus-ascii sounds like a good approach. > > Cheers, > otluk > > > > Am Mi., 9. März 2022 um 15:19 Uhr schrieb Christofer Dutz < > [email protected]>: > > > Hi all, > > > > I'm currently working on the modbus RTU stuff ... as in general the > > protocols are referred to modbus-tcp, modbus-rtu und modbus-ascii, I > > would like to rename the "modbus" to "modbus-tcp" ... While modbus-tcp > > will not be many variants, will the modbus-rtu and ascii also be > > available as "modbus-rtu:tcp" if a tcp tunnel is used. > > > > What do you think? > > > > Chris > > >
