+1 x 3 -K
----- Original Message ----- > On 03/18/2011 03:56 PM, Justin Ross wrote: > > On Fri, 18 Mar 2011, Robert Godfrey wrote: > > > >> I know Gordon said: > >> > >> > >> "Specifically I'd suggest that unless anyone has specific updates > >> to the > >> following artefacts - and volunteers to verify the artefact for the > >> release > >> - we remove them from the published list: > >> > >> qpid-dotnet-0-8-0.10-beta.zip > >> qpid-dotnet-0-10-0.10-beta. > >> zip > >> qpid-ruby-0.10-beta.tar.gz > >> > >> This will avoid giving false impressions about ongoing maintenance > >> for > >> these > >> clients" > >> > >> But I think that if we are going to actually do this, we should > >> formally > >> vote for it, and move the codebases for these artefacts into an > >> "attic" > >> directory or similar. > >> > >> I'm not against removing unloved and unmaintained code... but I do > >> feel that > >> we should vote before adding or removing artefacts to/from the > >> release. > > > > Okay. I'll restore these to RC2 unless there's a vote to remove > > them. > > I would find it hard to vote for a new release that contained those > artefacts unless someone could justify it through a list of changes > made[1] (this would also have the benefit of identifying possible > maintainers for those components to whom questions of support could be > directed). I.e. I think that a vote will be required to keep them in, > and it would be unfortunate to stall the whole release. > > However I do agree that some more explicit 'consensus gathering' on > this > is important since my previous mail did not result in any comments or > responses. Therefore... > > ...please reply with your +1 / -1 vote, or cross one of the boxes for > each of the cases below: > > (a) > > [ ] +1, qpid-dotnet-0-8-0.10 SHOULD be removed from the 0.10 release > [ ] -1, qpid-dotnet-0-8-0.10 should NOT be removed from the 0.10 > release (please list changes it includes to support this vote) > > (b) > > [ ] +1, qpid-dotnet-0-10-0.10 SHOULD be removed from the 0.10 release > [ ] -1, qpid-dotnet-0-10-0.10 should NOT be removed from the 0.10 > release (please list changes it includes to support this vote) > > (c) > > [ ] +1, qpid-ruby-0.10 SHOULD be removed from the 0.10 release > [ ] -1, qpid-ruby-0.10 should NOT be removed from the 0.10 release > (please list changes it includes to support this vote) > > > [1] My JIRA query may be at fault, but I can't see any JIRA for any of > those components fixed for 0.9/0.10 > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > Apache Qpid - AMQP Messaging Implementation > Project: http://qpid.apache.org > Use/Interact: mailto:[email protected] --------------------------------------------------------------------- Apache Qpid - AMQP Messaging Implementation Project: http://qpid.apache.org Use/Interact: mailto:[email protected]
