Sorry to miss the context. Repost again :-) Hi,
As the topic said, I would like to put forward this issue despite we are apache tlp project. Firstly. we must arrange the total projects outside of Apache Repository[3]. According to my work on Apache RocketMQ Externals, CPP client[1] is a contribution from Alibaba, which is outside of Apache Repository. Could anyone add else? If no, I suggest we re-check what we have done about all external projects [2]. [1] https://github.com/apache/rocketmq-externals/tree/master/rocketmq-cpp [2] https://github.com/apache/rocketmq-externals [3] http://incubator.apache.org/ip-clearance/ Best Regards, Von Gosling 2017-03-20 17:04 GMT+08:00 Von Gosling <[email protected]>: > Hi, > > > Perhaps like Justin > > said above, getting ICLAs from the contributors and having the potential > > committer discussion about each of them right away. > > > > Actually, i was also puzzled about this contribution behavior coming from > some Apache Project Community. I have been investing other Apache TLP works > about here. They get them involved in through the same git repository, or > leave them alone, just through one formal link to touch these community > projects. But as for us, we hope to merge the mature project to our > repository, let it under Apache RocketMQ’s umbrella. So, that’s why we > provided the Github group RocketMQ firstly, hoping to gathering them > together. We define the mature project as those were used in product > environment massively, like the RocketMQ-JMS and RocketMQ-Console projects > from the RocketMQ’s first marathon campaign :-) > > > > 在 2017年3月19日，01:26，Bruce Snyder <[email protected]> 写道： > > > > Thanks for raising this question, Justin, as there is an important > > distinction here. > > > > Since the code that was not part of the core RocketMQ and was recently > > moved to the externals project was not migrated as part of the original > > move from Github to the ASF, it must be treated a bit differently. This > is > > especially true if folks who are not currently committers to the ASF > > RocketMQ project contributed to that code. We should have taken a more > > formal approach to moving over this code (my mistake for not recognizing > > this sooner). In terms of voting in the folks who contributed to this > code > > when it resided at Github vs. now that it resides at the ASF, there must > be > > a formal discussion of this amongst the PPMC about these potential > > committers in order to make this decision just like any other potential > > committers. > > > > It's also important to recognize that the ASF cannot provide the same > legal > > guarantees for code that was not officially contributed to the ASF vs. > code > > that goes through the proper legal process that has been established over > > the years at the ASF (like the original core RocketMQ code went through). > > This what code grants are all about and an important tenant of why the > ASF > > exists. I'm honestly not quite sure what to do here. Perhaps like Justin > > said above, getting ICLAs from the contributors and having the potential > > committer discussion about each of them right away. > > > > Justin, what are your further thoughts on this second topic? > > > > Bruce > > > > On Thu, Mar 16, 2017 at 8:43 PM, Justin Mclean <[email protected] > > > > wrote: > > > >> Hi, > >> > >>> And we want to adopt the same way in the second code marathon: > >>> 1. Launch and develop the sub project in [1] at the initial stage. > >>> 2. Migrate the stable and fully functional sub projects to > >>> rocketmq-externals, meanwhile vote the top contributors as a committer. > >>> > >>> Does it ok ? > >> > >> I think I have a couple of issues with this: > >> 1. Code that hasn’t been reviewed for possible IP or legal issues is > >> copied into the Apache repo. > >> 2. We may not have ICLAs for the contributors. > >> 3. You are voting on committer based on their contribution to an > external > >> project not this Apache project. > >> > >> What do the other mentors think? > >> > >> Thanks, > >> Justin > > > > > > > > > > -- > > perl -e 'print > > unpack("u30","D0G)U8V4\@4VYY9&5R\"F)R=6-E+G-N>61E<D\!G;6%I;\"YC;VT*" );' > > > > ActiveMQ in Action: http://bit.ly/2je6cQ > > Blog: http://bsnyder.org/ <http://bruceblog.org/> > > Twitter: http://twitter.com/brucesnyder > > -- Nothing is impossible
