Do you consider performance/scale of SolrCloud or corectness (shards with no leader, replicas not recovering, non functional Overseer etc) as the most important areas for improvement if we were to move to a v2?
Ilan Le sam. 10 avr. 2021 à 22:37, Mark Miller <[email protected]> a écrit : > Now a I was saying ... SolrCloud2. Well, some people don’t like the name - > fair enough - I don’t like purple much and I didn’t invent either... so > Solr2. > > > > I have some thoughts, a few things to offer. Yes, the guy behind a lot of > the current garbage. They asked me my thoughts on this thing on day one - I > told them I don’t have a single one, let me have a go and I’ll get back to > you. Done and done. > > > So yeah, Solr2. Wait, what’s that ... ? Loud dance floor out here - if I > could have the floor for just a moment. I’ve put just a little bit of time > and effort in before grabbing the mic. A modicum. My ego, my job, my > status, my history, really not part of the equation, so if I could request > a few lines before the rebuttal and correction and redirection. No hurry > for those things, they are patient characters. > > > Anyway, give me a moment, and in return I’ll spare you the long winded > diversions. > > > Having considered Solr2 for some time, I see all kinds of roadblocks and > restraints and limitations. I see a path fraught with the potential to > mimic previous paths. And my goodness, I’m getting old. Fresh, promising > paths please. So Ive invested some time and effort to establish an escape > route from the safe, conservative hack and slash through the jungle that > gets less safe the deeper we dive. I’d simply tell you about it, but jungle > stories are all heart and no soul and we will all trade them all day. > > > So I’ve got some notes and code and maps and journals and crap instead. > Compiled from a couple expeditions. From before spelunking made me an old > man. So my machete isn’t solo diving any new trails, single handedly > slaying jungle cats any longer. The blade just keeps getting duller. > > > But I’ve got these previous materials. I’ll lay them out. Take a look. If > we can explore and discuss with just a passing courtesy of respect for our > relative time and investment and focus put in before letting loose, I’m > sure we can move beyond basic software counter meandering quickly enough to > actually enter the jungle. > > > I’ll try and lay out some evidence to help here. For instance, that > zookeeper is not the issue. That the overseer is not the issue. That > modules and multitudes of features are not the issue. Previous efforts are > not the issue. Object oriented development and agile frameworks are not the > issue. And yet all remain pertinent software development conversation. Bike > shed rainbows. You can make beautiful multicolored bike sheds with all of > them. > > > But discuss colors with someone else please. I can’t do it anymore. But > I can discuss some jungle hack and slash momentum and trail blazing. Give > me a moment. Time is fairly irrelevant on this dance floor. Tomorrow. Next > year. 3 years. Solr 42. It’s all the same timeline when the time comes. > Hell, my brain feels equally everywhere in all the timelines anyway. So one > moment, and I’ll point you to my speech, my journals, my old jungle dune > buggy - I did spend a moment or two once or twice preparing the damn thing > - just a moment or two, just 1, 2 or 3 times - and then the microphone is > all yours. But please, don’t talk to me about rainbows or shades of > magenta, I’m a jungle explorer, not a Sherwin Williams employee. Don’t > cover me with paint - I’m a roto spinning paint spewing machine. And I’d > love to spare you the paint ball war as well. > > > Links coming. > > > Mark > > > > -- > - Mark > > http://about.me/markrmiller >
