On Thu, Jun 15, 2017 at 7:52 AM Sam Ruby <ru...@intertwingly.net> wrote:
> On Thu, Jun 15, 2017 at 7:12 AM, John D. Ament <johndam...@apache.org> > wrote: > > Not sure what could have caused it. > > > > - MADlib looks correct > > The ✘ at the top means no podlingnamesearch was found (hover over it > to see the tooltip). > > Anirudh Kondaveeti's id is incorrect (the correct id is akondave) > > Orhan Kışlal's name doesn't match the name in LDAP (which is recorded > as Orhan Kislal, note the s). > > Not that it is a problem, but I note that MADlib's PPMC roster was > never set up. I mention that as (per below) it is a check that now > occurs to me should be added. > > > - Atlas isn't processing as an establish (not sure why) > > Email addresses aren't enclosed in <>s, and the lines aren't preceded > by an asterisk. Note that this parsed list was by the tlp establish > infra tool; but that need may soon go away with the changes in LDAP. > In any case, the failure to parse this list means that the > cross-checks that the board agenda tool does to see if ids are valid > and names match aren't performed. > > Not checked by the current board agenda tool, but I note that the > people listed as Atlas committers in LDAP are being proposed as PPMC > members in the resolution. > > The quotes around the chair's name may cause it to not match the email > addresses once they are fixed. > > > - Mynewt only picks up Justin's name, no one else's > > No asterisks, extra comma at the end of lines. Again, committers are > listed as proposed PMC members. > > Committers being added to the PMC shouldn't be an issue. > Justin is found as he is listed as the chair. > > > John > > P.S. The roster tool has a button at the bottom of PPMC pages which > helps generate a correctly formatted establish resolution. At the > moment, it only presents the resolution, which can be copied/pasted. > It could have an option to post the resolution, either to the > incubator mailing list for a vote or to the board agenda itself. >
