I would be careful setting up a repository which closely "tracks" the SVN repository at the ASF. I don't know if their servers will see it as a DoS attack or not. I seem to remember someone playing around with Git and getting their IP address blocked or some other trouble when trying to hit the ASF SVN server pretty hard. I don't know how much traffic your git tracking will cause, but if it's going to be somewhat significant, a quick note to [EMAIL PROTECTED] might be a good idea. I'm very ignorant when it comes to git, so forgive me if my fears are unfounded. :)
On a separate note, if you guys are the only ones contributing to the portal support and have been the ones maintaining it, perhaps the Wicket PMC will consider adding you as committers. I'm not on the PMC so I can't speak for them, though. But, if you are the ones contributing such a big piece of functionality, I think you have a pretty strong case. On Fri, Oct 10, 2008 at 12:04 PM, Antony Stubbs <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Fine, but myself and the couple of other people who want to work on this > don't have commit access to a branch on svn, so one of the many features of > Git is it allows us to easily setup a repository, and branches, while > tracking the Wicket repo, allowing us to collaborate much more effectively > than exchanging patch files. > > Having a branch what we could commit to on the apache wicket svn would > alleviate a lot of those issues, but that's probably not going to happen. > > I'm not going to hi-jack this thread, but there are multitudes of reasons > why Git > SVN. > > I'm kind of surprised by your comments Jonathan as the person who started > Wicket after all :) > > 2008/10/10 James Carman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > >> On Fri, Oct 10, 2008 at 11:35 AM, Jonathan Locke >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> > -1 >> > >> > i'm sick of new version control systems. i want simple eclipse >> integration >> > and since SVN finally works for me i wish people would stick with it. >> >> Agreed! The git vs. svn discussion had been done before in different >> ASF forums and the bottom line is that the ASF uses SVN (currently) >> for its version control. Also, since source work is not supposed to >> be done "behind closed doors" (ASF is all about community) it's best >> if the work is done using the SVN repository. >> > > > > -- > ___________________________ > http://stubbisms.wordpress.com/ >
