Just a reminder: you are on a wrong list. This list is intendet for core xdoclet, and plugins are discussed in another. see
http://xdoclet.codehaus.org/Mailing+lists ( but anyway, you message is received. but not by everybody :) ) --- Paul Galbraith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I'm curious what you think of trying to keep the > hibernate tagnames > matching the mapping DTD one for one. We try hard to achieve this. But given speed oh changes in hibernate DTDs it is not easy... > For example, <join> has a <key> subelement in the > mapping DTD, so I > would prefer to have hibernate tags named > @hibernate.join (which we > have) and @hibernate.key (which is currently > join-key instead). If it is the same element and receives the same parameters, it shall keep the same name... If possible... > For cases where a element-tag is ambiguous and may > be placed in more > than one parent element, then the parent element > could have an > "element-id" parameter and the child could have a > "parent-element-ref" > parameter, to explicitly specify how the mapping > should be formed. > > I think this strategy ultimately makes life a lot > easier for the user, > as they only need to reference the hibernate > documentation and mapping > DTD in order to write their java class (with very > few exceptions, > anyways). Any mapping element naturally translates > to a @hibernate tag > of the same name so there's no need to go hunting > through xdoclet > documentation to find the tag that does what you > need. We try to follow DTD as closely as possible. > I'm hoping to implement a strategy like this for the > xdoclet 1.3 > release, but I won't if it makes migration to > xdoclet 2 by changing > basic tag names... Are you commiter of XD1? ( Me too, but I'm inactive since switching to XD2 completely ) I'm still wondering why people still use XD1 for hibernate ( ok, XD2 plugin for EJB is not usable due to lack of use case of developers )... > Any thoughts? POint us where we can improve our tags. ( Best with test covcered patches in JIRA :) ) regards, ----[ Konstantin Pribluda ( ko5tik ) ]---------------- ... Auf der Suche nach einen Projekt in Rhein-Main ab 18.4.2005 ----[ http://www.pribluda.de ]------------------------ __________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Make Yahoo! your home page http://www.yahoo.com/r/hs
